MNK99
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 5,560
- Deleted by MNK99
REDDITORS are all communists. I haven't posted in 10-12 years. Pharma shills and 5-6 incel mods that run every group (so they can bully people online I guess).
I actually hope most of R/Toronto dies tbh, and I haven't interacted with them in over a decade.
r/Hypermobility icon
Go to Hypermobility
r/Hypermobility
•
2 yr. ago
mystic_eejit
Has anyone tried the carnivore diet?
Discussion
I have hypermobility and have been trying out the carnivore diet. I am getting great results. I feel less inflamed and my joints do not hurt any more. Used to suffer greatly from arthritis to the point where I couldn't walk. I felt like I was turning into a statue. I feel that carbs and inflammation are connected, in my case anyway. My arthritis flares up when I eat carbs and foods high in oxalate. When I eat meat I feel great. My stomach feels fine, I'm less anxious, clearer head. From my own personal experience a animal fat based diet appears to be very beneficial.
Anyway, just wondering what this subreddits opinion is of the carnivore diet and if anyone here has tried it?
Locked post. New comments cannot be posted.
Upvote
13
Downvote
60
comments
Share
Share
Sort by:
Best
Search Comments
Expand comment search
Life_in_a_lane
•
2y ago
I find lower gluten and carbs but find meat hard to digest.
The Mediterranean diet with low gluten and carbs makes me feel the best.
Listen to your body; everyone is different.
Upvote
17
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
u/tits-n-teeth avatar
tits-n-teeth
•
2y ago
Ha I went the opposite way and have been following a whole food plant diet for over a year now. I noticed such a difference in inflammation, recovery time and also my skin is amazing now!
Upvote
16
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
Do you have hypermobility? Do you eat meat or you straight vegan?
Upvote
2
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
u/tits-n-teeth avatar
tits-n-teeth
•
2y ago
I have EDS. No meat, wouldn't class myself as vegan either as this could include all sorts of crap as long as cruelty free. Strictly whole plant foods.
Upvote
6
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
Interesting. Not sure is it a good idea because a lot of people seem to go carnivore to heal the bad effects of going vegan. Just being honest. At the end of the day you can eat what you want but don't say I didn't warn you. Do you try and get into ketosis ?
Upvote
-9
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
Ilana___
•
2y ago
The people who damage themselves on a plant based diet are not eating a balanced diet and getting all the nutrients they need. Plant based diets have been proven to be one of the healthiest diets you can consume because animal products can be inflammatory. The same thing can be said about carnivore diet, you can cannot get the vitamins and nutrients you need by just eating protein and fat. Please actually look into the science and peer reviewed scientific studies instead of going on anecdotes. You can do real harm to your body.
Upvote
13
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
u/tits-n-teeth avatar
tits-n-teeth
•
2y ago
Funny because in my experience people go vegan to heal the bad effects from eating meat. Don't say I didn't warn you
Upvote
11
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
Each to their own. I'm not here to tell people what to eat. Just the carnivore diet has helped me and wondering what other hypermobile people think of it.
Upvote
-1
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
u/tits-n-teeth avatar
tits-n-teeth
•
2y ago
Really?? Cause from your last reply and most of your comment history it sounds ALOT like you're here to tell people what to eat.
Upvote
9
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
All I'm saying is carnivore should be considered a perfectly legitimate diet for people who are dealing with chronic inflammation. I am biased towards carnivore diet, I give you that, because I have had great results from it. A lot of people in the carnivore community are also getting great results from it. I started this thread just to have a discussion because I'm just trying to understand my condition and why am I so chronically ill. Before carnivore, my arthritis was so bad it would leave me bed bound. After eating just meat, I can now go for a jog or a hike. I honestly think a lot of hypermobilers would see great benefit of ditching sugar and going carnivore. I'm justing putting this idea out there in case it might help somebody. Let the people look at the arguments and decide what the will have for dinner.
Upvote
-2
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
Electronic_Emu
•
2y ago
The Maintenance Phase podcast did a couple of episodes on the carnivore diet. There can be cons to it like it damages gut bacteria which is very hard to repair.
Upvote
14
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
Yeah that is an issue but to overcome that problem you ease into the diet. Like you wean your self of potatos week by week so you let your gut biome adapt to the new way of eating. If you go straight carnivore the bacteria that used to eat the sugar and plant matter literally start eating you.
Are you hypermobile and have you tried eating carnivore / keto diet?
Upvote
3
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
Electronic_Emu
•
2y ago
I have hypermobility. I haven't tried eating either. I've worked with a registered dietician, and I feel better with a wider range of food groups.
Upvote
7
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
Ilana___
•
2y ago
The maintenance phase also pointed out how detrimental it can be even if you wean into it. You can really mess up the vitamins and minerals you need. It can be deadly.
Upvote
10
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
u/redTanto avatar
redTanto
•
2y ago
There was nothing mechanistic in their podcast. Zero. Nada. Zilch.
Upvote
1
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
ExtraGloria
•
2y ago
Close to it a few times and I never felt worse on a diet
Upvote
10
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
How long did you try the diet?
Upvote
1
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
ExtraGloria
•
2y ago
A few weeks in a few occasions. Listen, it’s a stupid diet that isn’t evidence based in terms of a diet that’s remotely good for you , I was doing it to lose fat.
Upvote
13
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
Fair enough, that is your opinion and you can eat what you want. Yet I have to object to the fact that a meat based diet isn't good for you. It's basically the diet we evolved to eat. Human beings are meant to run on fat and not sugar. When humans went from hunting to farming, our health went down hill and hasn't recovered. I believe that us hypermobilers are so ill because we cannot deal with the modern high carb / low nutrients diet that prevails in the west. We're prone to inflammation and eating inflammatory sugar isn't going to help us. I have gone carnivore and I went from bedridden to being able to run on the beach. I just want to discuss this diet as a possible way of healing our hypermobile body's.
Upvote
-7
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
Ilana___
•
2y ago
Our ancestors were not carnivores. Our molars are proof that we have been omnivores since apes evolved into apes. We had a balanced diet of foraged vegetables and fruit as well as meat. I agree we weren’t designed for simple sugars, high carbs, and processed food. The best anti inflammatory diets are whole food diets with lean protein, fresh produce, and whole grains like our ancestors ate before agriculture. Eating only meat means that you won’t get the essential vitamins and nutrients that we need, especially us hypermobile folk. As well as only eating meat can cause you to have too much vitamin A and iron which can be deadly. The podcast, the maintenance phase has episodes on jordan Peterson and they deep dive into the evidence and the efficiency of the diet. I deeply encourage you to listen to that podcast before you go on that diet because it can be deadly.
Upvote
13
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
The reason we are human is that we hunted animals and ate their flesh. How else do we have a such a tiny stomach and huge brain.To power our huge brain we ate meat and we were powered by fat. Oddly, when we switched to agriculture and a carb based diet, our health has nose dived and we never recovered. You can see it in the archaeological record. The Innuit eat mostly meat and are fine. You should read Not by Bread Alone by Vilhjalmur Stefansson. He gives an account of living with the Innuit and living on a zero carb /meat based diet. He says they were perfectly healthy eating basically only meat and he never felt better than when on the diet. There are many groups of people that survive on meat based diet. You will not be nutritionally deprived on the diet. I have been following many people in the carnivore diet and they seem to thrive on it.
In regards to us hypermobilers, carnivore is the ultimate elimination diet. So if something your eating is irritating you can figure it out by going carnivore, then adding stuff back in. Like I know I can't eat oxalate high food as they will poison me. Look up a nutritionist by the name of Sally Norton as she is on a crusade to tell people about the dangers of oxalate. My theory is that the natural toxins in plants can not be handled by our hypermobile intestines. They just filter straight through and settle into our bodies and joints causing inflamation.
I personally think carnivore and zero carb is a perfectly valid diet for people who are trying to tackle auto immune issues that come with hypermobility.
Upvote
-7
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
WookieRubbersmith
•
2y ago
Do you have any sources to back the claim that humans were way healthier prior to the agricultural revolution?
I am having trouble wrapping my head around how that could possibly be quantifiably, objectively true, given that the average human is so much longer now than at any previous point in history. Like, if people were just absolutely thriving on this magical diet...why didn't they live longer?
You also haven't really addressed the dispute of your claim that humans, on a general and widespread level, previously subsisted on meat alone (as opposed to foraging for edible plants and fungi in addition). It seems like there is widespread, easily available information disputing this claim. What has you so convinced that pre-agricultural humans were exclusive carnivores?
Upvote
5
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
I can give you two articles to start with.
Here is an article that goes into how agriculture ruined our oral health, caused nutritional deficiencies and caused a loss in height. Amongst other things
Here is an article that argues that humanoids evolved into hypercarnivores.
Hope that helps. The science backs up my points. Just saying.
Upvote
-1
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
ExtraGloria
•
2y ago
Okay Joe rogan
Upvote
5
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
ExtraGloria
•
2y ago
My opinion means jack shit, I'm going to refer to pretty much all of the registered dieticians I have spoken to including a professor at a prestigious university.
Upvote
9
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
spoookytree
•
2y ago
I find a keto diet works best for me because it reduces inflammation, helps my tummy, and helps my brain. Carnivore is pretty close though
I actually hope most of R/Toronto dies tbh, and I haven't interacted with them in over a decade.
r/Hypermobility icon
Go to Hypermobility
r/Hypermobility
•
2 yr. ago
mystic_eejit
Has anyone tried the carnivore diet?
Discussion
I have hypermobility and have been trying out the carnivore diet. I am getting great results. I feel less inflamed and my joints do not hurt any more. Used to suffer greatly from arthritis to the point where I couldn't walk. I felt like I was turning into a statue. I feel that carbs and inflammation are connected, in my case anyway. My arthritis flares up when I eat carbs and foods high in oxalate. When I eat meat I feel great. My stomach feels fine, I'm less anxious, clearer head. From my own personal experience a animal fat based diet appears to be very beneficial.
Anyway, just wondering what this subreddits opinion is of the carnivore diet and if anyone here has tried it?
Locked post. New comments cannot be posted.
Upvote
13
Downvote
60
comments
Share
Share
Sort by:
Best
Search Comments
Expand comment search
Life_in_a_lane
•
2y ago
I find lower gluten and carbs but find meat hard to digest.
The Mediterranean diet with low gluten and carbs makes me feel the best.
Listen to your body; everyone is different.
Upvote
17
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
u/tits-n-teeth avatar
tits-n-teeth
•
2y ago
Ha I went the opposite way and have been following a whole food plant diet for over a year now. I noticed such a difference in inflammation, recovery time and also my skin is amazing now!
Upvote
16
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
Do you have hypermobility? Do you eat meat or you straight vegan?
Upvote
2
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
u/tits-n-teeth avatar
tits-n-teeth
•
2y ago
I have EDS. No meat, wouldn't class myself as vegan either as this could include all sorts of crap as long as cruelty free. Strictly whole plant foods.
Upvote
6
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
Interesting. Not sure is it a good idea because a lot of people seem to go carnivore to heal the bad effects of going vegan. Just being honest. At the end of the day you can eat what you want but don't say I didn't warn you. Do you try and get into ketosis ?
Upvote
-9
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
Ilana___
•
2y ago
The people who damage themselves on a plant based diet are not eating a balanced diet and getting all the nutrients they need. Plant based diets have been proven to be one of the healthiest diets you can consume because animal products can be inflammatory. The same thing can be said about carnivore diet, you can cannot get the vitamins and nutrients you need by just eating protein and fat. Please actually look into the science and peer reviewed scientific studies instead of going on anecdotes. You can do real harm to your body.
Upvote
13
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
u/tits-n-teeth avatar
tits-n-teeth
•
2y ago
Funny because in my experience people go vegan to heal the bad effects from eating meat. Don't say I didn't warn you
Upvote
11
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
Each to their own. I'm not here to tell people what to eat. Just the carnivore diet has helped me and wondering what other hypermobile people think of it.
Upvote
-1
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
u/tits-n-teeth avatar
tits-n-teeth
•
2y ago
Really?? Cause from your last reply and most of your comment history it sounds ALOT like you're here to tell people what to eat.
Upvote
9
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
All I'm saying is carnivore should be considered a perfectly legitimate diet for people who are dealing with chronic inflammation. I am biased towards carnivore diet, I give you that, because I have had great results from it. A lot of people in the carnivore community are also getting great results from it. I started this thread just to have a discussion because I'm just trying to understand my condition and why am I so chronically ill. Before carnivore, my arthritis was so bad it would leave me bed bound. After eating just meat, I can now go for a jog or a hike. I honestly think a lot of hypermobilers would see great benefit of ditching sugar and going carnivore. I'm justing putting this idea out there in case it might help somebody. Let the people look at the arguments and decide what the will have for dinner.
Upvote
-2
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
Electronic_Emu
•
2y ago
The Maintenance Phase podcast did a couple of episodes on the carnivore diet. There can be cons to it like it damages gut bacteria which is very hard to repair.
Upvote
14
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
Yeah that is an issue but to overcome that problem you ease into the diet. Like you wean your self of potatos week by week so you let your gut biome adapt to the new way of eating. If you go straight carnivore the bacteria that used to eat the sugar and plant matter literally start eating you.
Are you hypermobile and have you tried eating carnivore / keto diet?
Upvote
3
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
Electronic_Emu
•
2y ago
I have hypermobility. I haven't tried eating either. I've worked with a registered dietician, and I feel better with a wider range of food groups.
Upvote
7
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
Ilana___
•
2y ago
The maintenance phase also pointed out how detrimental it can be even if you wean into it. You can really mess up the vitamins and minerals you need. It can be deadly.
Upvote
10
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
u/redTanto avatar
redTanto
•
2y ago
There was nothing mechanistic in their podcast. Zero. Nada. Zilch.
Upvote
1
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
ExtraGloria
•
2y ago
Close to it a few times and I never felt worse on a diet
Upvote
10
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
How long did you try the diet?
Upvote
1
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
ExtraGloria
•
2y ago
A few weeks in a few occasions. Listen, it’s a stupid diet that isn’t evidence based in terms of a diet that’s remotely good for you , I was doing it to lose fat.
Upvote
13
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
Fair enough, that is your opinion and you can eat what you want. Yet I have to object to the fact that a meat based diet isn't good for you. It's basically the diet we evolved to eat. Human beings are meant to run on fat and not sugar. When humans went from hunting to farming, our health went down hill and hasn't recovered. I believe that us hypermobilers are so ill because we cannot deal with the modern high carb / low nutrients diet that prevails in the west. We're prone to inflammation and eating inflammatory sugar isn't going to help us. I have gone carnivore and I went from bedridden to being able to run on the beach. I just want to discuss this diet as a possible way of healing our hypermobile body's.
Upvote
-7
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
Ilana___
•
2y ago
Our ancestors were not carnivores. Our molars are proof that we have been omnivores since apes evolved into apes. We had a balanced diet of foraged vegetables and fruit as well as meat. I agree we weren’t designed for simple sugars, high carbs, and processed food. The best anti inflammatory diets are whole food diets with lean protein, fresh produce, and whole grains like our ancestors ate before agriculture. Eating only meat means that you won’t get the essential vitamins and nutrients that we need, especially us hypermobile folk. As well as only eating meat can cause you to have too much vitamin A and iron which can be deadly. The podcast, the maintenance phase has episodes on jordan Peterson and they deep dive into the evidence and the efficiency of the diet. I deeply encourage you to listen to that podcast before you go on that diet because it can be deadly.
Upvote
13
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
The reason we are human is that we hunted animals and ate their flesh. How else do we have a such a tiny stomach and huge brain.To power our huge brain we ate meat and we were powered by fat. Oddly, when we switched to agriculture and a carb based diet, our health has nose dived and we never recovered. You can see it in the archaeological record. The Innuit eat mostly meat and are fine. You should read Not by Bread Alone by Vilhjalmur Stefansson. He gives an account of living with the Innuit and living on a zero carb /meat based diet. He says they were perfectly healthy eating basically only meat and he never felt better than when on the diet. There are many groups of people that survive on meat based diet. You will not be nutritionally deprived on the diet. I have been following many people in the carnivore diet and they seem to thrive on it.
In regards to us hypermobilers, carnivore is the ultimate elimination diet. So if something your eating is irritating you can figure it out by going carnivore, then adding stuff back in. Like I know I can't eat oxalate high food as they will poison me. Look up a nutritionist by the name of Sally Norton as she is on a crusade to tell people about the dangers of oxalate. My theory is that the natural toxins in plants can not be handled by our hypermobile intestines. They just filter straight through and settle into our bodies and joints causing inflamation.
I personally think carnivore and zero carb is a perfectly valid diet for people who are trying to tackle auto immune issues that come with hypermobility.
Upvote
-7
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
WookieRubbersmith
•
2y ago
Do you have any sources to back the claim that humans were way healthier prior to the agricultural revolution?
I am having trouble wrapping my head around how that could possibly be quantifiably, objectively true, given that the average human is so much longer now than at any previous point in history. Like, if people were just absolutely thriving on this magical diet...why didn't they live longer?
You also haven't really addressed the dispute of your claim that humans, on a general and widespread level, previously subsisted on meat alone (as opposed to foraging for edible plants and fungi in addition). It seems like there is widespread, easily available information disputing this claim. What has you so convinced that pre-agricultural humans were exclusive carnivores?
Upvote
5
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
mystic_eejit
OP
•
2y ago
I can give you two articles to start with.
Here is an article that goes into how agriculture ruined our oral health, caused nutritional deficiencies and caused a loss in height. Amongst other things
Here is an article that argues that humanoids evolved into hypercarnivores.
Hope that helps. The science backs up my points. Just saying.
Upvote
-1
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
ExtraGloria
•
2y ago
Okay Joe rogan
Upvote
5
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
ExtraGloria
•
2y ago
My opinion means jack shit, I'm going to refer to pretty much all of the registered dieticians I have spoken to including a professor at a prestigious university.
Upvote
9
Downvote
Award
Share
Share
spoookytree
•
2y ago
I find a keto diet works best for me because it reduces inflammation, helps my tummy, and helps my brain. Carnivore is pretty close though