MNK99
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 5,560
- Deleted by MNK99
Member
JoinedSep 27, 2015Messages543LocationMinnesota
Seems pretty obvious that he's gbol.
Sep 21, 2020
Thread Starter
#459
J
JoeKool
Member
JoinedMar 3, 2017Messages299
@Unknownuser did you always have mcas? I don't think tyrosine will harm anything but did the glycine coincide with this down turn?
This Is your 7th week? I can only say your starting point could be further back from others so these hormonal swings might just be par for the course. I can't recall feeling like a fresh pfs crash ever on it, but could you be feeling, since you had some Improvements, that your downturn is compared to that but your baseline is actually up? And maybe It was just too much muscle activity too soon? I'm praying for ya but try to relax and stay cool
Sep 21, 2020
#460
U
Unknownuser
Member
JoinedAug 11, 2020Messages185
@joekool My mcas started in 2012, after the bad trip on weed that ended in hospital. Wednesday week 7 will start yes. Ok I call it crash but of course its not like crashing after stopping fin in 2005. I mean crash in terms of CFS feeling came back, libido is zero, depressive, brain fog etc. So, yes, back to baseline. On Saturday, before the massage, I even felt my **** was fleshier the last few days. Unerected it felt and looked fuller instead of thin like a pencil or kids penis.
As I said, I had these kind of recoveries before. In January 2020 (started BPC 157, DHEA, Pregnenolone) I had a pretty great recovery that kept going on for 1-2 months, when I had a new gf. I had great sex twice a day with her in the beginning. But after 5-6 weeks I crashed somehow (still on DHEA and Preg.) and started to avoid sex again. I even remember, I had this kind of recovery in 2017, when I did not even knew I had PFS. This time I had 2 weeks daily very nice sex with my ex gf. The problem is, I have these recoveries for some short time and then "crash" again to baseline for some reason. In these baseline times I dont want to even think about sex, it feels disgusting to think about sex. So you told me in an older post, this happens when prolactin goes up right? Or I get some DHT overload the receptors cant handle? DHT in my blood was pretty high. But it looks like it does not work. Because ever since I started fin, my hairnloss stopped. This test was done in mid 2019 before I took any DHEA etc.
j6VJup8.jpg
Whatever it is, I hope with hcg I can keep these recoveries forever and end the cycle that keeps me crashing.
Last
#464
M
Mister
Member
JoinedAug 12, 2020Messages821
Am I wrong or is @Fairplay Helen? Sounds the same
Yup seems like it, spamming nonesense, helping nobody and having a guru/messiah complex.
It is not about HCG or clomid, or proviron, it is how you use them ,you clown. Obviously, it is nothing new, it is about the confidence that it works and why it works, and in what order and how. All these doctors have no clue. And as you can see in those threads that you posted most people who saw them did not recover and tons of people saw them from propeciahelp and none recovered.
Cdnuts protocol pumps LH, same as HCG which is LH basically. . Clomid downregulates ERa. Go on hackstasis and ask 5-alpha, he was on clomid for 2 years. Ask him did it help his PFS or not. Oh, wait , I forgot , you are banned.
the quote from Dr.Shippen
"Doctor Shippen told me that some of his patients who never recovered were unable to produce adequate amounts of DHT. He believes that Propecia switched off a gene or something like that, perhaps one that controls the conversion of testosterone to DHT."
Hilarious BS.
Lol Helen (you probably) don't even know what to recommend people, the "understanding pfs" thread on hackstasis was clear. You don't know ***t. And the arrogance of you thinking to know more than an endo, just lol.
And of course not everyone got cured from their protocol, atleast a big part got better unlike the people on hackstasis who have been reading your crap for years, thank god JoeKool got better by testing things himself.
I know that Dr. Shippen has had some success with restoring the HPTA with drugs like Clomid and HCG, and that in other cases, he’s had success with testosterone replacement therapy. He’s treated about 20 different guys with long-term problems after quitting fin, and he claims to have a success rate of 50 to 75%
Now why are you still here? You guys hated this forum and made hackstasis, go back to your sh*thole and stay away.
Sep 22, 2020
#465
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
Yup seems like it, spamming nonesense, helping nobody and having a guru/messiah complex.
Lol Helen (you probably) don't even know what to recommend people, the "understanding pfs" thread on hackstasis was clear. You don't know ***t. And the arrogance of you thinking to know more than an endo, just lol.
And of course not everyone got cured from their protocol, atleast a big part got better unlike the people on hackstasis who have been reading your crap for years, thank god JoeKool got better by testing things himself.
I know that Dr. Shippen has had some success with restoring the HPTA with drugs like Clomid and HCG, and that in other cases, he’s had success with testosterone replacement therapy. He’s treated about 20 different guys with long-term problems after quitting fin, and he claims to have a success rate of 50 to 75%
Now why are you still here? You guys hated this forum and made hackstasis, go back to your sh*thole and stay away.
Hilarious, I said that in the threads that you posted about Dr Shippen and Crisler, folks went to see them from the actual propeciahelp forum. And no one recovered , as you can read their reviews in those threads. If anyone from propeciahelp recovered by using them , then TONS of people would have recovered by following the same regimen. Get a brain. You need to read those threads that you posted and read Awor comments who actually called the office of Dr Shippen about this 50 to 75%. And the actual office told him that they dont have any success with PFS yet.
As I already told you, go ask 5-alpha on HS about his 2 years experiment with clomid.
"Lol Helen (you probably) don't even know what to recommend people, the "understanding pfs" thread on hackstasis was clear. You don't know ***t. And the arrogance of you thinking to know more than an endo, just lol."
Funny is that why people feel recovered in that thread? within couple of weeks .
Sep 22, 2020
#466
M
Mister
Member
JoinedAug 12, 2020Messages821
Hilarious, I said that in the threads that you posted about Dr Shippen and Crisler, folks went to see them from the actual propeciahelp forum. And no one recovered , as you can read their reviews in those threads. If anyone from propeciahelp recovered by using them , then TONS of people would have recovered by following the same regimen. Get a brain. You need to read those threads that you posted and read Awor comments who actually called the office of Dr Shippen about this 50 to 75%. And the actual office told him that they dont have any success with PFS yet.
As I already told you, go ask 5-alpha on HS about his 2 years experiment with clomid.
"Lol Helen (you probably) don't even know what to recommend people, the "understanding pfs" thread on hackstasis was clear. You don't know ***t. And the arrogance of you thinking to know more than an endo, just lol."
Funny is that why people feel recovered in that thread? within couple of weeks .
I rather believe what the endos said than what one guy on propeciahelp said about these recoveries. And of course not everyone got better, just like all the years on hackstasis you didn't get anyone recovered with your gibberish theories.
You didn't help anyone, JoeKool is the one that showed his HCG protocol worked and this encouraged members to try it, not because of you/Helen, lmfao the arrogance of trying to steal JoeKool's credit is a new low for you/Helen.
Anyway, good for other people to read about Hackstatis having no integrity and how Helen got exposed for being the wannabe guru, trying to steal other people's credit.
Sep 22, 2020
#467
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
@Mister Joekool was a moderator of Hackstasis for 3 years, together with Helen and Boris. And all this info is coming from there, and this thread also is from there. So if not for Hackstasis you wont have this thread here. Joekool was giving the study about HCG in 2018 by Helen( I can post the thread) . But he continued to run TRT and argued like crazy all the time.
Hackstasis forum started when Helen came to Ray Peat, and said that PFS is similar to Deca ****. And suggested Clomid protocol. FYI
Joekool was the first one to try it. Helen suggested bromocriptine while on clomid to destroy AR. protein levels. Similar to what Sospian Ran for his Deca **** in this thread.
Tons of people recovered from Deca **** using that protocol. Caber plus clomid or HCG. Or proviron then clomid or HCG.
That is how Hackstasis forum started. Ask Joekool, if he is man enough NOT TO LIE.
Hilarious.
Last edited: Sep 22, 2020
Sep 22, 2020
#468
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
@Mister Are you dumb or are you pretending. I am suggesting a different protocol. Proviron first to downregulate AR, and then when VDR works, downregulate ERa.
and as you can see in this thread.
Sospian. ran proviron, then HCG , recovered within couple weeks. Also ran bromo.
Slader ran R andro(DHT derivative) now HCG, and feels better. Has GABA problem ,possible since andro was a gaba agonist.
Rebel on Hackstasis( proviron, then HCG) , it has not been 2 weeks yet, but his emotion, libido erections all recovered
TYR1 ( ran proviron, watch him do great now on HCG)
Now, Joekool's victims
Newyorker - 9 weeks HCG , Nothing.
Unknownuser- 7 weeks, crashing form POIS. Notice, Rebel also had POIS in PFS. it is gone within first week of HCG.
Ingeno- 10 weeks depression, quit, then ran another 5 weeks, quit NOTHING.
Andy5( hackstasis 14 weeks HCG-- NOthing.
Mcurtone 15 weeks HCG- nothing.
may be HCG also works solo, and you need these 6 months. you might.
or it worked for Joekool since he is taking vit D and still taking it.
No one is trying to steal anything or claim anything, I am just looking at the progress and results without any bias.
Of course Joe pushed people to try HCG, that was on Hackstasis , I hope you understand that, this post was posted on Hackstasis and later it showed up here . Boris and Helen constantly told him to pump LH. and he was doing the opposite with TRT. and then he took their advice.
And since he was the only one experimenting with hormonal routes, he recovered.
It is very good that Joe feels recovered, but sometimes he just does not understand things and I am trying to figure it out. I give him credit for sure for being a warrior.
And when he posted that he is recovered on hackstasis , tons of people went on the protocol.
And Helen did trials of it. But we did not yield any results so far.
People felt similar to Newyorker.
And some folks who ran proviron right before , feel recovered at once.
You see the difference.
Last edited: Sep 22, 2020
Sep 22, 2020
#469
sladerunner69
sladerunner69
Member
JoinedMay 24, 2013Messages3,307Age31LocationLos Angeles
Unbelievable, the Hackstasis cult with this Helen person at the helm banned me there because I dared to say Fairlplay shouldn't bring drama here.
Let this be a warning to others, this Helen guy there acts as a "know it all" guru figure that wanted to take all the credit for Joekool's recovery.
Good to know hackstasis forum has no integrity and does not allow for any criticism.
I'm fairly certain that @Fairplay is in fact Helen from hackstasis (formerly goldbuev- who came on her a few years back and caused a huge circus when he claimed he intentionally gave himself PFS and then cured it by fasting and taking the abortion pill. He has helped a number of guys though.) The double line spacing, the confusing logic, the writing style is all too unmistakable. Nothing personal but your advice had always raised more questions than answers for me.
For instance:
@sladerunner69
Effects of Subchronic Finasteride Treatment and Withdrawal on Neuroactive Steroid Levels and Their Receptors in the Male Rat Brain - PubMed
you block 5AR, this upregulates androgen receptor and GABA while on FIN.
you quit FIN, you have upregulated AR, upregulated ERa , downregulated ERb, and downregulated GABA.
As you can see from this study.
The reason why this happens, is when you go off fin, DHT levels go up, this hits AR, AR suppresses your VDR signaling, vitamin D receptor.
Prolactin is the hormone which rises when you need calcium. It converts vitamin D into its active form.
so as AR is blocking your VDR, this upregulates ERa to pump noradrenaline, and raises prolactin to provide more vitamin D.
since VDR is blocked, you have not working sympathetic nervous system, since noradrenaline works on calcium. Thus GABA also downregulates to match low sympathetic tone.
so as AR upregulates, this blocks VDR, which then upregulates ERa the same amount as it downregulates GABA.
As you can see , this is the description of the study ABOVE.
So now you take DHT derivative( R andro) . this downregulates your AR in the brain. So now your VDR is not blocked by AR anymore.
So your calcium metabolism works. So your noradrenaline, your opiods, your nitric oxide works since calcium is needed for all those enzyme to work.
So now as your VDR is unblocked, if you increase hormones with HCG, it gives you emotions, erections and Energy. HCG is LH, it downregulates ERa ,so when you come off HCG you wont be suppressed.
But as estrogen rises on HCG, you need more GABA to match. Rememeber GABA downregulated previously to match NOT working VDR .
So you are taking HCG which is trying to downregulate ERa, HCG pumps your sympathetic nervous system since increasing your estro.
So this estro should upregulate your GABA receptor over time, unless HCG downregulates ERA faster than GABA manages to upregulate.
From the very first line I am not following you. Finasteride upregulated the androgen receptor? That's certainly not what I experienced when on propecia. I couldn't get an erection and my pecker shrank up to 1/2 size and was a light shade of blue. I felt depressed and weak. Nothing like "increased androgen receptor". The abstract you posted doesn't actually clarify whether the androgen and GABA receptors were increased or decreased, just that they were modified significantly so as to influence "broad changes to the cerebro-nervous system." The full text is behind a paywall - Effects of Subchronic Finasteride Treatment and Withdrawal on Neuroactive Steroid Levels and Their Receptors in the Male Rat Brain. It's $50. Did you purchase it? If so, please send it to me if you can.
The rest of your logic after this seems alright, but is too mechanical for my taste. Receptors don't tend to respond in a predictable, calculated manner. Rather, they work along a gradient, and are more deeply influenced by the context of the whole metabolism. Having high DHT won't necessarily reduce the dht receptor, and vice-versa. Peat wrote about this quite a bit, not with DHT but other hormones such as testosterone and progesterone.
But let's say you are correct in your interpretation of receptor theory, and Peat is wrong. We need to prove that the androgen receptor has been unregulated, because that seems to be the basis of your theory. Where is the evidence of that?
Last edited: Sep 22, 2020
Sep 22, 2020
#470
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
@sladerunner69 Effects of Subchronic Finasteride Treatment and Withdrawal on Neuroactive Steroid Levels and Their Receptors in the Male Rat Brain - PubMed
The enzymatic conversion of progesterone and testosterone by the enzyme 5alpha-reductase exerts a crucial role in the control of nervous function. The effects of finasteride in the brain, an inhibitor of this enzyme used for the treatment of human benign prostatic hyperplasia and androgenic alopecia, have been poorly explored. Therefore, the effects of a subchronic treatment with finasteride at low doses (3 mg/kg/day) and the consequences of its withdrawal on neuroactive steroid levels in plasma, cerebrospinal fluid and some brain regions as well as on the expression of classical and non-classical steroid receptors have been evaluated in male rats. After subchronic treatment (i.e., for 20 days) the following effects were detected: (i) depending on the compartment considered, alteration in the levels of neuroactive steroids, not only in 5alpha-reduced metabolites but also in its precursors and in neuroactive steroids from other steroidogenic pathways and (ii) an upregulation of the androgen receptor in the cerebral cortex and beta3 subunit of the GABA-A receptor in the cerebellum. One month after the last treatment (i.e., withdrawal period), some of these effects persisted (i.e., the upregulation of the androgen receptor in the cerebral cortex, an increase of dihydroprogesterone in the cerebellum, a decrease of dihydrotestosterone in plasma). Moreover, other changes in neuroactive steroid levels, steroid receptors (i.e., an upregulation of the estrogen receptor alpha and a downregulation of the estrogen receptor beta in the cerebral cortex) and GABA-A receptor subunits (i.e., a decrease of alpha 4 and beta 3 mRNA levels in the cerebral cortex) were detected. These findings suggest that finasteride treatment may have broad consequences for brain function.
Sep 22, 2020
#471
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
@sladerunner69 .
"
From the very first line I am not following you. Finasteride upregulated the androgen receptor? That's certainly not what I experienced when on propecia. I couldn't get an erection and my pecker shrank up to 1/2 size and was a light shade of blue. I felt depressed and weak."
While on finasteride, you nuke your DHT levels, So it does not matter if your AR is upregulated or downregulated , you simply have no DHT to even hit it. That is why you had your pecker disappear. but Brain AR upregulated , no doubt about it.
Sep 22, 2020
#472
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
@sladerunner69
" But let's say you are correct in your interpretation of receptor theory, and Peat is wrong. We need to prove that the androgen receptor has been unregulated, because that seems to be the basis of your theory. Where is the evidence of that?"
The evidence of that is very easy. Jack17 went back on dutasteride which inhibits 5AR1 and 5AR2 low dosage.
And as long as he stays on dutasteride low dosage which kills his 5AR1 in the brain, he feels recovered from PFS.
You can go on hackstasis and search his thread. He has been recovered from PFS for more than a year now on this low dose dutasteride.
Same as you can see that folks on propecia help feel recovered on nandrolone which blocks DHT.
So basically if you block DHT receptor slighly and pump TEST, you feel recovered.
Of course I am not suggesting blocking DHT. or going on dutasteride.
this is just to show you what PFS is.
JoinedSep 27, 2015Messages543LocationMinnesota
Seems pretty obvious that he's gbol.
Sep 21, 2020
Thread Starter
#459
J
JoeKool
Member
JoinedMar 3, 2017Messages299
@Unknownuser did you always have mcas? I don't think tyrosine will harm anything but did the glycine coincide with this down turn?
This Is your 7th week? I can only say your starting point could be further back from others so these hormonal swings might just be par for the course. I can't recall feeling like a fresh pfs crash ever on it, but could you be feeling, since you had some Improvements, that your downturn is compared to that but your baseline is actually up? And maybe It was just too much muscle activity too soon? I'm praying for ya but try to relax and stay cool
Sep 21, 2020
#460
U
Unknownuser
Member
JoinedAug 11, 2020Messages185
@joekool My mcas started in 2012, after the bad trip on weed that ended in hospital. Wednesday week 7 will start yes. Ok I call it crash but of course its not like crashing after stopping fin in 2005. I mean crash in terms of CFS feeling came back, libido is zero, depressive, brain fog etc. So, yes, back to baseline. On Saturday, before the massage, I even felt my **** was fleshier the last few days. Unerected it felt and looked fuller instead of thin like a pencil or kids penis.
As I said, I had these kind of recoveries before. In January 2020 (started BPC 157, DHEA, Pregnenolone) I had a pretty great recovery that kept going on for 1-2 months, when I had a new gf. I had great sex twice a day with her in the beginning. But after 5-6 weeks I crashed somehow (still on DHEA and Preg.) and started to avoid sex again. I even remember, I had this kind of recovery in 2017, when I did not even knew I had PFS. This time I had 2 weeks daily very nice sex with my ex gf. The problem is, I have these recoveries for some short time and then "crash" again to baseline for some reason. In these baseline times I dont want to even think about sex, it feels disgusting to think about sex. So you told me in an older post, this happens when prolactin goes up right? Or I get some DHT overload the receptors cant handle? DHT in my blood was pretty high. But it looks like it does not work. Because ever since I started fin, my hairnloss stopped. This test was done in mid 2019 before I took any DHEA etc.
j6VJup8.jpg
Whatever it is, I hope with hcg I can keep these recoveries forever and end the cycle that keeps me crashing.
Last
#464
M
Mister
Member
JoinedAug 12, 2020Messages821
Am I wrong or is @Fairplay Helen? Sounds the same
Yup seems like it, spamming nonesense, helping nobody and having a guru/messiah complex.
It is not about HCG or clomid, or proviron, it is how you use them ,you clown. Obviously, it is nothing new, it is about the confidence that it works and why it works, and in what order and how. All these doctors have no clue. And as you can see in those threads that you posted most people who saw them did not recover and tons of people saw them from propeciahelp and none recovered.
Cdnuts protocol pumps LH, same as HCG which is LH basically. . Clomid downregulates ERa. Go on hackstasis and ask 5-alpha, he was on clomid for 2 years. Ask him did it help his PFS or not. Oh, wait , I forgot , you are banned.
the quote from Dr.Shippen
"Doctor Shippen told me that some of his patients who never recovered were unable to produce adequate amounts of DHT. He believes that Propecia switched off a gene or something like that, perhaps one that controls the conversion of testosterone to DHT."
Hilarious BS.
Lol Helen (you probably) don't even know what to recommend people, the "understanding pfs" thread on hackstasis was clear. You don't know ***t. And the arrogance of you thinking to know more than an endo, just lol.
And of course not everyone got cured from their protocol, atleast a big part got better unlike the people on hackstasis who have been reading your crap for years, thank god JoeKool got better by testing things himself.
I know that Dr. Shippen has had some success with restoring the HPTA with drugs like Clomid and HCG, and that in other cases, he’s had success with testosterone replacement therapy. He’s treated about 20 different guys with long-term problems after quitting fin, and he claims to have a success rate of 50 to 75%
Now why are you still here? You guys hated this forum and made hackstasis, go back to your sh*thole and stay away.
Sep 22, 2020
#465
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
Yup seems like it, spamming nonesense, helping nobody and having a guru/messiah complex.
Lol Helen (you probably) don't even know what to recommend people, the "understanding pfs" thread on hackstasis was clear. You don't know ***t. And the arrogance of you thinking to know more than an endo, just lol.
And of course not everyone got cured from their protocol, atleast a big part got better unlike the people on hackstasis who have been reading your crap for years, thank god JoeKool got better by testing things himself.
I know that Dr. Shippen has had some success with restoring the HPTA with drugs like Clomid and HCG, and that in other cases, he’s had success with testosterone replacement therapy. He’s treated about 20 different guys with long-term problems after quitting fin, and he claims to have a success rate of 50 to 75%
Now why are you still here? You guys hated this forum and made hackstasis, go back to your sh*thole and stay away.
Hilarious, I said that in the threads that you posted about Dr Shippen and Crisler, folks went to see them from the actual propeciahelp forum. And no one recovered , as you can read their reviews in those threads. If anyone from propeciahelp recovered by using them , then TONS of people would have recovered by following the same regimen. Get a brain. You need to read those threads that you posted and read Awor comments who actually called the office of Dr Shippen about this 50 to 75%. And the actual office told him that they dont have any success with PFS yet.
As I already told you, go ask 5-alpha on HS about his 2 years experiment with clomid.
"Lol Helen (you probably) don't even know what to recommend people, the "understanding pfs" thread on hackstasis was clear. You don't know ***t. And the arrogance of you thinking to know more than an endo, just lol."
Funny is that why people feel recovered in that thread? within couple of weeks .
Sep 22, 2020
#466
M
Mister
Member
JoinedAug 12, 2020Messages821
Hilarious, I said that in the threads that you posted about Dr Shippen and Crisler, folks went to see them from the actual propeciahelp forum. And no one recovered , as you can read their reviews in those threads. If anyone from propeciahelp recovered by using them , then TONS of people would have recovered by following the same regimen. Get a brain. You need to read those threads that you posted and read Awor comments who actually called the office of Dr Shippen about this 50 to 75%. And the actual office told him that they dont have any success with PFS yet.
As I already told you, go ask 5-alpha on HS about his 2 years experiment with clomid.
"Lol Helen (you probably) don't even know what to recommend people, the "understanding pfs" thread on hackstasis was clear. You don't know ***t. And the arrogance of you thinking to know more than an endo, just lol."
Funny is that why people feel recovered in that thread? within couple of weeks .
I rather believe what the endos said than what one guy on propeciahelp said about these recoveries. And of course not everyone got better, just like all the years on hackstasis you didn't get anyone recovered with your gibberish theories.
You didn't help anyone, JoeKool is the one that showed his HCG protocol worked and this encouraged members to try it, not because of you/Helen, lmfao the arrogance of trying to steal JoeKool's credit is a new low for you/Helen.
Anyway, good for other people to read about Hackstatis having no integrity and how Helen got exposed for being the wannabe guru, trying to steal other people's credit.
Sep 22, 2020
#467
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
@Mister Joekool was a moderator of Hackstasis for 3 years, together with Helen and Boris. And all this info is coming from there, and this thread also is from there. So if not for Hackstasis you wont have this thread here. Joekool was giving the study about HCG in 2018 by Helen( I can post the thread) . But he continued to run TRT and argued like crazy all the time.
Hackstasis forum started when Helen came to Ray Peat, and said that PFS is similar to Deca ****. And suggested Clomid protocol. FYI
Joekool was the first one to try it. Helen suggested bromocriptine while on clomid to destroy AR. protein levels. Similar to what Sospian Ran for his Deca **** in this thread.
Tons of people recovered from Deca **** using that protocol. Caber plus clomid or HCG. Or proviron then clomid or HCG.
That is how Hackstasis forum started. Ask Joekool, if he is man enough NOT TO LIE.
Hilarious.
Last edited: Sep 22, 2020
Sep 22, 2020
#468
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
@Mister Are you dumb or are you pretending. I am suggesting a different protocol. Proviron first to downregulate AR, and then when VDR works, downregulate ERa.
and as you can see in this thread.
Sospian. ran proviron, then HCG , recovered within couple weeks. Also ran bromo.
Slader ran R andro(DHT derivative) now HCG, and feels better. Has GABA problem ,possible since andro was a gaba agonist.
Rebel on Hackstasis( proviron, then HCG) , it has not been 2 weeks yet, but his emotion, libido erections all recovered
TYR1 ( ran proviron, watch him do great now on HCG)
Now, Joekool's victims
Newyorker - 9 weeks HCG , Nothing.
Unknownuser- 7 weeks, crashing form POIS. Notice, Rebel also had POIS in PFS. it is gone within first week of HCG.
Ingeno- 10 weeks depression, quit, then ran another 5 weeks, quit NOTHING.
Andy5( hackstasis 14 weeks HCG-- NOthing.
Mcurtone 15 weeks HCG- nothing.
may be HCG also works solo, and you need these 6 months. you might.
or it worked for Joekool since he is taking vit D and still taking it.
No one is trying to steal anything or claim anything, I am just looking at the progress and results without any bias.
Of course Joe pushed people to try HCG, that was on Hackstasis , I hope you understand that, this post was posted on Hackstasis and later it showed up here . Boris and Helen constantly told him to pump LH. and he was doing the opposite with TRT. and then he took their advice.
And since he was the only one experimenting with hormonal routes, he recovered.
It is very good that Joe feels recovered, but sometimes he just does not understand things and I am trying to figure it out. I give him credit for sure for being a warrior.
And when he posted that he is recovered on hackstasis , tons of people went on the protocol.
And Helen did trials of it. But we did not yield any results so far.
People felt similar to Newyorker.
And some folks who ran proviron right before , feel recovered at once.
You see the difference.
Last edited: Sep 22, 2020
Sep 22, 2020
#469
sladerunner69
sladerunner69
Member
JoinedMay 24, 2013Messages3,307Age31LocationLos Angeles
Unbelievable, the Hackstasis cult with this Helen person at the helm banned me there because I dared to say Fairlplay shouldn't bring drama here.
Let this be a warning to others, this Helen guy there acts as a "know it all" guru figure that wanted to take all the credit for Joekool's recovery.
Good to know hackstasis forum has no integrity and does not allow for any criticism.
I'm fairly certain that @Fairplay is in fact Helen from hackstasis (formerly goldbuev- who came on her a few years back and caused a huge circus when he claimed he intentionally gave himself PFS and then cured it by fasting and taking the abortion pill. He has helped a number of guys though.) The double line spacing, the confusing logic, the writing style is all too unmistakable. Nothing personal but your advice had always raised more questions than answers for me.
For instance:
@sladerunner69
Effects of Subchronic Finasteride Treatment and Withdrawal on Neuroactive Steroid Levels and Their Receptors in the Male Rat Brain - PubMed
you block 5AR, this upregulates androgen receptor and GABA while on FIN.
you quit FIN, you have upregulated AR, upregulated ERa , downregulated ERb, and downregulated GABA.
As you can see from this study.
The reason why this happens, is when you go off fin, DHT levels go up, this hits AR, AR suppresses your VDR signaling, vitamin D receptor.
Prolactin is the hormone which rises when you need calcium. It converts vitamin D into its active form.
so as AR is blocking your VDR, this upregulates ERa to pump noradrenaline, and raises prolactin to provide more vitamin D.
since VDR is blocked, you have not working sympathetic nervous system, since noradrenaline works on calcium. Thus GABA also downregulates to match low sympathetic tone.
so as AR upregulates, this blocks VDR, which then upregulates ERa the same amount as it downregulates GABA.
As you can see , this is the description of the study ABOVE.
So now you take DHT derivative( R andro) . this downregulates your AR in the brain. So now your VDR is not blocked by AR anymore.
So your calcium metabolism works. So your noradrenaline, your opiods, your nitric oxide works since calcium is needed for all those enzyme to work.
So now as your VDR is unblocked, if you increase hormones with HCG, it gives you emotions, erections and Energy. HCG is LH, it downregulates ERa ,so when you come off HCG you wont be suppressed.
But as estrogen rises on HCG, you need more GABA to match. Rememeber GABA downregulated previously to match NOT working VDR .
So you are taking HCG which is trying to downregulate ERa, HCG pumps your sympathetic nervous system since increasing your estro.
So this estro should upregulate your GABA receptor over time, unless HCG downregulates ERA faster than GABA manages to upregulate.
From the very first line I am not following you. Finasteride upregulated the androgen receptor? That's certainly not what I experienced when on propecia. I couldn't get an erection and my pecker shrank up to 1/2 size and was a light shade of blue. I felt depressed and weak. Nothing like "increased androgen receptor". The abstract you posted doesn't actually clarify whether the androgen and GABA receptors were increased or decreased, just that they were modified significantly so as to influence "broad changes to the cerebro-nervous system." The full text is behind a paywall - Effects of Subchronic Finasteride Treatment and Withdrawal on Neuroactive Steroid Levels and Their Receptors in the Male Rat Brain. It's $50. Did you purchase it? If so, please send it to me if you can.
The rest of your logic after this seems alright, but is too mechanical for my taste. Receptors don't tend to respond in a predictable, calculated manner. Rather, they work along a gradient, and are more deeply influenced by the context of the whole metabolism. Having high DHT won't necessarily reduce the dht receptor, and vice-versa. Peat wrote about this quite a bit, not with DHT but other hormones such as testosterone and progesterone.
But let's say you are correct in your interpretation of receptor theory, and Peat is wrong. We need to prove that the androgen receptor has been unregulated, because that seems to be the basis of your theory. Where is the evidence of that?
Last edited: Sep 22, 2020
Sep 22, 2020
#470
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
@sladerunner69 Effects of Subchronic Finasteride Treatment and Withdrawal on Neuroactive Steroid Levels and Their Receptors in the Male Rat Brain - PubMed
The enzymatic conversion of progesterone and testosterone by the enzyme 5alpha-reductase exerts a crucial role in the control of nervous function. The effects of finasteride in the brain, an inhibitor of this enzyme used for the treatment of human benign prostatic hyperplasia and androgenic alopecia, have been poorly explored. Therefore, the effects of a subchronic treatment with finasteride at low doses (3 mg/kg/day) and the consequences of its withdrawal on neuroactive steroid levels in plasma, cerebrospinal fluid and some brain regions as well as on the expression of classical and non-classical steroid receptors have been evaluated in male rats. After subchronic treatment (i.e., for 20 days) the following effects were detected: (i) depending on the compartment considered, alteration in the levels of neuroactive steroids, not only in 5alpha-reduced metabolites but also in its precursors and in neuroactive steroids from other steroidogenic pathways and (ii) an upregulation of the androgen receptor in the cerebral cortex and beta3 subunit of the GABA-A receptor in the cerebellum. One month after the last treatment (i.e., withdrawal period), some of these effects persisted (i.e., the upregulation of the androgen receptor in the cerebral cortex, an increase of dihydroprogesterone in the cerebellum, a decrease of dihydrotestosterone in plasma). Moreover, other changes in neuroactive steroid levels, steroid receptors (i.e., an upregulation of the estrogen receptor alpha and a downregulation of the estrogen receptor beta in the cerebral cortex) and GABA-A receptor subunits (i.e., a decrease of alpha 4 and beta 3 mRNA levels in the cerebral cortex) were detected. These findings suggest that finasteride treatment may have broad consequences for brain function.
Sep 22, 2020
#471
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
@sladerunner69 .
"
From the very first line I am not following you. Finasteride upregulated the androgen receptor? That's certainly not what I experienced when on propecia. I couldn't get an erection and my pecker shrank up to 1/2 size and was a light shade of blue. I felt depressed and weak."
While on finasteride, you nuke your DHT levels, So it does not matter if your AR is upregulated or downregulated , you simply have no DHT to even hit it. That is why you had your pecker disappear. but Brain AR upregulated , no doubt about it.
Sep 22, 2020
#472
F
Fairplay
Member
JoinedAug 28, 2020Messages75
@sladerunner69
" But let's say you are correct in your interpretation of receptor theory, and Peat is wrong. We need to prove that the androgen receptor has been unregulated, because that seems to be the basis of your theory. Where is the evidence of that?"
The evidence of that is very easy. Jack17 went back on dutasteride which inhibits 5AR1 and 5AR2 low dosage.
And as long as he stays on dutasteride low dosage which kills his 5AR1 in the brain, he feels recovered from PFS.
You can go on hackstasis and search his thread. He has been recovered from PFS for more than a year now on this low dose dutasteride.
Same as you can see that folks on propecia help feel recovered on nandrolone which blocks DHT.
So basically if you block DHT receptor slighly and pump TEST, you feel recovered.
Of course I am not suggesting blocking DHT. or going on dutasteride.
this is just to show you what PFS is.