Hack Stasis Forum

MNK99

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,560
  • Deleted by MNK99
MyUsernameHere
Member
JoinedNov 16, 2012
Messages1,100
Dr Jimmy said:
I am doing the protocol.

BUT

It is a long protocol and i expect FULL sexual/mental recovery, not x% improvement.

I am feeling good on hcg and if i werent PAS sufferer i also would do it for its safety and potential benefits. but i am still thinking about time.

You shouldn't have expectations like that, as it is quite unlikely to work like that. Even well researched diseases with well researched treatments (is there such a thing?) don't produce 100% idealistic results like that.

Here we are talking about a vastly underresearched condition for which no clinically verified treatment plan exists, but random protocols cobbled together on forums from sufferers.

It might take more 'runs'. You might have to use different compounds intermittently or alongside HCG. There is no guarantee that a one-off course is going to fix you completely. The only thing you can hope for is that you get better, and as long as you are improving, you can very well be thankful for that. A lot of us here spent several years with no tangible improvement in our condition and would've given our balls (figuratively speaking) for "x% improvement". If you need any proof of that just look at the miserables on PropeciaHelp and the kinds of posts they make daily.

I don't mean this personally, just want to put things in perspective that beggars can't be choosers, and PFS sufferers are most certainly beggars when it comes to options. Everything that helps... helps.
Dec 29, 2020

P

Peatfan69​

Member​

JoinedFeb 26, 2018Messages147
You can't possibly say that you've read this thread thoroughly and haven't seen a single report of improvement when I have literally posted an update a page ago where I write about getting better sexually (granted I have used other stuff not just HCG). Fairly sure a few other people have posted good results in this thread as well.
Who has had permanent improvement or was cured from the actual OP protocol in this thread? I have checked here and PH and I haven't seen anything - quite the opposite actually. I'm just being honest here since you are going to be wasting many months to a year on this protocol for literally nothing.

Like I said every one reporting good improvements is not on the OP protocol but instead is adding other things in including yourself.

The logs that I read who were actually following in the OP's protocol did not have long term improvement actually many of them got off early because they felt even worse and couldn't even finish it (estrogen issue etc.). The ones that did have some sort of improvement were adding in other things in like proviron, tamox, diet changes etc.


P

Peatfan69​

Member​

JoinedFeb 26, 2018Messages147
Another one with improvements with HCG: JoeKool’s story: Long term HCG Newyorker
He has not completed the protocol - he is still on HCG. Reducing some of his symptoms while on is not the actual cure or permanent improvement. He could easily stop HCG tomorrow and by next week he will be back to baseline - this is the issue we are talking about when we say permanent.

He even said it himself:

My new endocrinologist says I can stay on hCG 12 months at this low dose. I suspect if the estrogen goes down to normal, I can stop the hCG and see what happens. I am hoping and praying for relief from this curse, and that this helps us, even if only partially.


M

Mister​

Member​

JoinedAug 12, 2020Messages821
He has not completed the protocol - he is still on HCG. Reducing some of his symptoms while on is not the actual cure or permanent improvement. He could easily stop HCG tomorrow and by next week he will be back to baseline - this is the issue we are talking about when we say permanent.

He even said it himself:

My new endocrinologist says I can stay on hCG 12 months at this low dose. I suspect if the estrogen goes down to normal, I can stop the hCG and see what happens. I am hoping and praying for relief from this curse, and that this helps us, even if only partially.
Newyorker has PFS for 15 years and he said this (funny you're not quoting him completely huh...)

"I’ve got about a month and a half to go for being on hCG six months. So far, even with the setbacks, these are the best and longest lasting improvements I’ve had since pfs started. It’s nowhere near normal, but so much better than before."

"I definitely have PFS and wonder since I’ve had it for so long, about 15 years, what else it may have affected. For sure, it absolutely shrunk my testicles, and since the hCG, they’ve come back to “normal” size, as per a doctor’s evaluation and a cat scan/mri that was taken for my back. This “normal” size is 2x what they were before hCG."


You expect a man that has PFS for 15 years to get completely recovered after a couple of months on HCG? The fact he is seeing so many improvements for the first time in all those years is amazing.

Like many others here who tried it, many report a lot of improvements. Everyone is different too, some need more time to heal than others or higher dosage, etc.


--haters.. someone coming back again.. to show ppl only he can cure people or it is someone else. GOD /messiah complex but negative, rather ev1 suffer than them not get the credit.
Very damaging esp to sensitive people that needed help. Shameful.

or maybe that person means welll and fucks up at times and has mania/ autism or something.

and this is just some PROPECIA help troll like PVDL, or like VKg1. Or any number of hateful and miserable trolls that will bring you down.

That's what 'Mister' thinks:

"Lol, starting to think this troll is Vkg1 from propeciahelp... You're a bit too transparent

Edit: oh now it all makes sense, Look at this guy's post history. He's just a guy with a hate boner for Joe."

--

Peatfan69​

Member​

JoinedFeb 26, 2018Messages147
I'm only attacking obvious trolls like you that try to dismiss HCG with nothing to back it up. You brought zero arguments or evidence and are dishonest that HCG doesn't help. Even now when everyone can see how you lie because you just don't like Joe for whatever petty reason, you try to dismiss a guy who has PFS for 15 years and has finally seen improvements for the first time in all these years that this is somehow not impressive? And long time sufferers like PAL who recovered faster doesn't prove anything, how hard is it for you to understand that everyone is different and some need more time, other dosage,...

Btw, to all reading here, this is his first post after lurking for years directed at Joe:

I remember your name now and went through your old posts. You left this forum years ago and made fun of ray peat and all his supporters here and now you are back here again using Ray Peat's name and community to push your own agenda (that you supposedly stole on top of that).

Please stop belittling other people in this thread as you have no right to as you made fun of Ray Peat and this community too. You just have no other forum to run to anymore so you came back here. I am actually surprised how you are not banned from this forum.


This troll obviously has a hate boner for Joe (maybe another alt of Helen or troll from hackstasis). Atleast a good troll would bring some arguments and proof that HCG is somehow not working for people with PFS. But shame on me for giving this troll attention in the first place.

Even more funny you're tying to create a narrative that HCG doesn't work when we recently had @ort123 making an excel about people who tried HCG on PH and showed many had positive experiences. HcG therapy - a summary of user experience
My evidence is here in this entire thread of 62 pages. It will be almost a year soon of when this original post here was made (March 2020) and the only positive anecdote you show is one guy who has been on HCG for 6 months who still has many remaining issues and remember this is while ON HCG not while off which is what matters.

Since you avoided the question the first time, I will ask you again - you had almost a year to try this protocol yet you have not so why are you defending this protocol so aggressively when you haven't even attempted it on your own? Like I said go create your own log and do it and prove us all wrong instead. You are always accusing other people of fake accounts once they dare question your master (the OP) but your account is the one starting to seem suspicious (JoeKool's second account???).

Getting temporary improvements is actually very easy in PFS. You want to feel better temporarily go on deca/NPP or TRT and deca. Better yet you even go microdose and go back on fin and you will feel better in some aspects. You will have some temporary improvements in some areas but the minute you come off you are back to square one.

Since you decided to pick and choose what you quote from New Yorker to here, I will post some of his other more realistic quotes after 6 months on HCG:


Ejaculate: it had turned to water during pfs. It’s now a little thicker, with a little bit of white color. After 15 years, I don’t remember what normal was, but it’s not there yet. This is an undeniable change in its texture. After intercourse, it would embarrassingly “leak out”, but this thicker ejaculate seems to be staying put more often.

Orgasm: under pfs, it was absolutely gone. It was a zero, sometimes with slight sensitivity after ejaculating. Orgasm got to 5-10% of normal since starting hCG, but after what seem like high estrogen symptoms, it’s back to zero, but with consistent sensitivity after orgasm.

Emotional effects: after getting out of my depression, I’ve regressed a bit. Definitely not like before, but not “happy” either. The joy of being depression free was a couple of weeks of bliss, and gives me hope to get out of it again.

Random erections: lots before pfs, zero after. With hCG, I’ve had two or three, always either sitting or in bed, and they are short lived.

Breast tissue/size. I’ve gained weight, so there is more there, and it’s come on slowing, so it’s difficult to gauge, but they seem larger. I distinctly remember during a high school entry medical exam, the doctor noted “feminization of the breasts” and that I would outgrow it. I always wondered how many of us may have had something like this, and if it could be an indicator of pfs risk.

Desire: it seems to have improved from zero to a tiny bit in the first couple of months of hCG. I was really hopefully to “make up for lost time”, but it’s back to almost zero again.



P

Peatfan69​

Member​

JoinedFeb 26, 2018Messages147
I have zero gain from saying this...

it is mostly working for me. I expect blips and I don’t believe HCG is perfect as it isn’t designed for this purpose. But most of the science supports the arguments made in favour of it and equally studies show its negatives (as with any drug).

I feel I have a balanced and open minded view on this protocol and I can honestly say it’s mostly positive. If you are expecting something that is 100% perfect and gives all pfs sufferers the recovery then you are going to be waiting forever (this doesn’t exist for any condition for that matter).

This is a battle and it’s pushing your body back in the right direction, HCG is simply a tool (one of many) for doing it. It’s not a binary yes or no. Fail or succeed. If it works for you then do it, if it doesn’t then something else will!

I have added a few different things into my protocol to suit my own needs. And I can tell you that prior to HCG these things didn’t help.
I'm just being honest and realistic here man. Mister posted a link to a spreadsheet of 22 people who tried HCG as evidence. About 50% of them had improvements while ON HCG which means nothing anecdotally since they get off and go back to baseline. The other 50% got negative symptoms or were unchanged. I don't think he understands that improvements while ON is not what we are considering as permanent improvements or even a cure which is literally the word used in this thread title.

I can name countless logs that show they improved from taking "X" supplement its actually pretty common.

And aren't you personally taking other supplements too?
 
Last edited: