@TubZy I've just been doing CDNuts protocol but by far my best time was last summer when I wasn't taking anything. So don't really know what's going on
How long have you been on this regimen? This is my own personal opinion, but herbs can dicey since they do so many things since they are loaded with different minerals and vitamins, they are hard to predict. Some respond to them greatly while others respond to a few and others respond to none (or feel worse). I was in the middle category, pine pollen I feel really weird on while others did OK on. So I basically stopped messing with herbs in general now or just one at a time if I was going to use it.
So if you felt better not taking herbs than don't take them IMO because there is something in one of them or all of them that is making you worse. If you felt better taking nothing, something in herbs are pushing out of balance again. I would say drop it and start higher up the chain and start simple maybe zinc finger or electrolytes then use process of elimination to fine tune it.
@gbolduev said it right, a few of those herbs can be great, but since you are cycling them in a huge rotation the other 19+ or so can be making you feel worse so it is hard to tell exactly how you are doing. Perfect example is licorice root.