EFA Deficiency with fat intakes equaling 10-30g/day

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
This is something I thought might be interesting to all the people who came here from the Peat universe.

Typically EFA deficiency only occurs in people during peritoneal nutrition or in infants, so I was surprised to hear how easily it's occurred in the past in adults on low-fat diets. There have been some case studies published where people on low-fat diets with fat malabsorption experience symptoms of EFA deficiency. When accounting for malabsorption, many of these people had total fat intakes as high as 35g/day - and I don't know if other people track their nutrient intake, but there's many days where my fat intake doesn't even hit 35g, or goes up around there. On average I found that I only eat about 50g/day and almost entirely saturated fat.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1610563/pdf/brmedj01975-0025.pdf

So it's important to take this into consideration, especially for everyone here who fasts regularly and maybe still carries some habits from their Peat days (No PUFA, only saturated fats, or low fat diets). Because it's very possible some people could be experiencing EFA deficiency. Many people here are also young, lean, and physical active - increasing the likelihood they could burn through EFA stores over a few years of doing this. Adding in metabolic stimulants like caffeine could exacerbate these symptoms as well, since it increases basal metabolism and fat oxidation. If you're low in cofactors for delta-6-desaturase (Mg, Fe, Zn, B2/B3/B6), I think this becomes more important. And again, it's important to feed in not just the end products (GLA, EPA, DHA) - but the precursors as well (LA, ALA). We don't want to bypass our bodies own regulation, especially when we are young and healthy. EFA deficiency is also a positive feedback loop, because EFA deficiency raises metabolic rate, which increases fat oxidation, which increases EFA deficiency, and so on. I'm not one who thinks we should pump ourselves up with PUFA, but it's important to note that they do serve some physiological role, and of course, balance is key.

Keep in mind the symptoms of EFA deficiency are:
- Increased respiratory rate + basal metabolism ("fast oxidation")
- Skin problems (scaly eczema, rashes) - sometimes mixed skin (oily and dry) is seen
- Impaired wound healing
- Hair loss & loss of color
- Thrombocytopenia (low platelets)
- Elevation of acute-phase reactants, e.g. ferritin
 

RebelWithACause

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,718
Nice.Thanks for the info. I also eat mostly saturated fat.

Is 1 egg a day good enough to get EFA in? I eat one whole egg (rest is egg whites) + sometimes some olive oil which also contains EFA I think. Not sure if this is enough.
 

SwaZ

Well-Known Member
Messages
426
Great info. My fat intake can be really high, up to 100g of fat a day, most of it coming from lard and eggs.

What are good non oxidized efa sources?
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
I don't think there are any hard and fast rules you can use to determine how much EFA you need. You need to take into account current nutrient deficiencies (EFA, Zn, Mg, Fe, B2/B3/B6), activity level, stress level, any fasting, caffeine intake, fat malabsorption (GI uptake, gallbladder secretion, pancreatic secretions), etc.

Like these cases show, a daily fat intake equal to 35g/day from mixed sources is enough to cause deficiency even in elderly people - who don't really burn a ton of fat. Right now recommendations are set at about 5g of n-3 and about 15g of n-6 per day, and I think those are mostly reasonable - especially if they are from sources high in Vitamin E. Flax seed and granola w/ seeds/nuts have been my go to for this. I also use butter and olive oil, but I don't use oils in any serious amounts so they don't provide much EFA in reality - 1 tbsp of butter provides like 0.3g of n-6 and that's it. Some seafood can be good for this too, but seafood is also quite lean for the most part (unless you eat fatty fish like salmon) so it barely provides any EFAs.

Just keep in mind this is actually harder to reach than you think. I ate 115g of protein and 70g of fat today - pork loin, duck breast, eggs, flax, granola with mixed seeds and nuts, yogurt, a pastry, some butter. I hit about 6g of n-3 and about 12g of n-6 so far, which isn't crazy high at all. If you eat even relatively healthy or low-fat hitting that 5/15 mark can actually be tough.
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
I think the Peat community has made a big deal about lipid peroxidation that's just unnecessary for most healthy people who don't eat massive amounts of PUFA everyday (mostly from processed oily foods). The reality is that during EFA deficiency, lipid peroxidation actually increases due to acute inflammation from impaired eicosanoid signalling (because the signalling continues using other fats, but it's dysfunctional because it's the wrong fat). That's why you see thrombocytopenia, rash, and high ferritin. It's just another U-curve relationship, almost like anything in nutrition (dysfunction at both ends of the spectrum).
 

Helen

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
5,415
Yes, but I am not sure if they count for fish that are likely more intoxicated than other seafood. They advised all kind of seafood and I'd like to pick the ones which are the least toxic.


they also rec'd to you nuts and seeds , did not they? you are a fast oxidizer
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
This is something I thought might be interesting to all the people who came here from the Peat universe.

Typically EFA deficiency only occurs in people during peritoneal nutrition or in infants, so I was surprised to hear how easily it's occurred in the past in adults on low-fat diets. There have been some case studies published where people on low-fat diets with fat malabsorption experience symptoms of EFA deficiency. When accounting for malabsorption, many of these people had total fat intakes as high as 35g/day - and I don't know if other people track their nutrient intake, but there's many days where my fat intake doesn't even hit 35g, or goes up around there. On average I found that I only eat about 50g/day and almost entirely saturated fat.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1610563/pdf/brmedj01975-0025.pdf

So it's important to take this into consideration, especially for everyone here who fasts regularly and maybe still carries some habits from their Peat days (No PUFA, only saturated fats, or low fat diets). Because it's very possible some people could be experiencing EFA deficiency. Many people here are also young, lean, and physical active - increasing the likelihood they could burn through EFA stores over a few years of doing this. Adding in metabolic stimulants like caffeine could exacerbate these symptoms as well, since it increases basal metabolism and fat oxidation. If you're low in cofactors for delta-6-desaturase (Mg, Fe, Zn, B2/B3/B6), I think this becomes more important. And again, it's important to feed in not just the end products (GLA, EPA, DHA) - but the precursors as well (LA, ALA). We don't want to bypass our bodies own regulation, especially when we are young and healthy. EFA deficiency is also a positive feedback loop, because EFA deficiency raises metabolic rate, which increases fat oxidation, which increases EFA deficiency, and so on. I'm not one who thinks we should pump ourselves up with PUFA, but it's important to note that they do serve some physiological role, and of course, balance is key.

Keep in mind the symptoms of EFA deficiency are:
- Increased respiratory rate + basal metabolism ("fast oxidation")
- Skin problems (scaly eczema, rashes) - sometimes mixed skin (oily and dry) is seen
- Impaired wound healing
- Hair loss & loss of color
- Thrombocytopenia (low platelets)
- Elevation of acute-phase reactants, e.g. ferritin
Great post!! Ive got thrombocytopenia, actually i suspect caused by accutane. I also have dry eyes, and fast oxidation. My skin gets oily still (why i went on accutane to begin with) but also dry in other areas... like my scalp w/ dandruff.
 
Last edited:

Helen

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
5,415
@mattyb High ferritin people are not fast oxidizers. usually pyroluric people with problems inserting iron into the ring. since ferrochelatase is impaired without glutathione reductase and active vitamin C and E.

Thus then this causes problems with the line before. zinc and B6.

and then these impair arachidonic acid formation. And LA is actually very high.


This was my case and pretty much 80% of cases of sick people.


I guess this is why Ray Peat wanted to avoid all Pufas, and rec'd mainly butter , lard etc. which help incredibly in these conditions. and contain tons of arachidonic acid. and GLA


Omegas caused extreme depression in these cases. and inflammation. in me included, ferritin was going higher and higher

Basically when there is zero histamine, there is no arachidonic acid formation. and pyroluria so called causes zero histamine. Since b2 is extremely low. and you get zero arachidonic acid


Fast oxidizers need more fats period, ALL fats. and usually have low ferritin,

When people fix their redox, they automatically fix their oils. and malaborbtion.

LIver flushes are also excellent for that.


As you said balance is the key. with fats. totally depleting Pufa is CRAZY I agree


but in impaired mito, IMO people should watch pufa at first. since taking pufa would kill redox more and more.

i think that is what Ray Peat meant
 
Last edited:

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
You're overgeneralizing. I would agree with you in some cases (well, maybe not about pyroluria) but EFA deficiency with iron sufficiency is unique.

EFA deficiency increases metabolic rate, the enhancement in metabolic rate = fast oxidation. If the person is iron sufficient (e.g. male), from years of doing things like eating meat and liver (Peat), then you get high ferritin because it's an acute phase reactant to the inflammation caused by dysfunctions in prostaglandin function, and there's enough spare iron in cells to displace it into ferritin to deal with oxidative stress. You see high ceruloplasmin AND high ferritin in EFA deficiency with iron sufficiency, which is kind of a unique combo. That's why you don't see any problems with real iron metabolism in these people - hemoglobin is still normal, iron levels are normal, TIBC, TF all normal. The only thing that's screwed up are thrombocytes, because they rely on AA for synthesis. Ferritin is just there to dampen ROS formation. Might see some increase in RBC hemolysis because they lyse easily if Mead content is high, but that's on the back end, not the front end.

In iron insufficiency + EFA deficiency you don't see any raised ferritin, you're more likely to see it lower.
 

mattyb

Moderator
Messages
833
Another thing to keep in perspective too is high circulating insulin levels which shut down lipolysis. This restricts access to stored EFAs, and deficiencies can develop even faster that way. Saw one study where they put people on parenteral nutrition for 7 days and they developed EFA deficiency in that time span. It was because of fat free diet + no lipolysis from constant infusion of glucose.
 

Helen

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
5,415
You're overgeneralizing. I would agree with you in some cases (well, maybe not about pyroluria) but EFA deficiency with iron sufficiency is unique.

EFA deficiency increases metabolic rate, the enhancement in metabolic rate = fast oxidation. If the person is iron sufficient (e.g. male), from years of doing things like eating meat and liver (Peat), then you get high ferritin because it's an acute phase reactant to the inflammation caused by dysfunctions in prostaglandin function, and there's enough spare iron in cells to displace it into ferritin to deal with oxidative stress. You see high ceruloplasmin AND high ferritin in EFA deficiency with iron sufficiency, which is kind of a unique combo. That's why you don't see any problems with real iron metabolism in these people - hemoglobin is still normal, iron levels are normal, TIBC, TF all normal. The only thing that's screwed up are thrombocytes, because they rely on AA for synthesis. Ferritin is just there to dampen ROS formation. Might see some increase in RBC hemolysis because they lyse easily if Mead content is high, but that's on the back end, not the front end.

In iron insufficiency + EFA deficiency you don't see any raised ferritin, you're more likely to see it lower.




I did not say anything about EFA deficiency, I said that high ferritin because of lack of redox , and problems with inserting iron into the ring is the most common problem among all these sick people. with high zinc prot. instead of iron. thus they have high pyrolles. there are no problems with hemoglobin in this case.
Glutathione reductase is not working and ascorbate and E are not there, thus ARA is closed. this is why if you feed these high ferritin people sodium ascorbate their ferritin drops.


LA levels are high in this case, and low GLA and ARA. ZInc is in the urine.

This is the common problem with all these CFS ME etc people. That is why all of them test for pyroluria, which is a not a condition really. but it is present in all of them.

It could be from low iron or redox deficiency , this condition. if they have low iron , then it causes problems with pyrolles , if they have normal iron but impaired redox, then ferrrochetalase will be impaired, and you will have high ferritin since iron would create ROS and without glutathione and SODS which will provide vit E and ascorbate it will be closed down, and imparied omega 6s. like ARA and GLA

since high pyrolles cause the enzymes before them inhibited and thus b6 and zinc dont work. This is what pyroluria is.

These people have EFA deficiency but it is not a primary imbalance. It is the cause of the imbalance above. I guess these are the people Ray Peat talks about. If they have too much wrong Pufa stored and if their metabolism subpar, they keep killing redox with these pufas and this does not allow their metabolism to ever lift up.

These are slow oxidizers usually. or 4 highs, which are slow under stress.



Now fast oxidizers.

Fast oxidation almost never have high ferritin. but I guess it is possible to have it high, I have never seen it. Since fast oxidation can handle oxidative stress no problem, thus they run on sugar metabolism. But never seen high ferritin ever in them only in 4 highs.

ferritin is always low, and iron is used highly to make FE S clusters to provide for hormones.

And of course these people run low on fats. as all fast oxidizers. and need to increase their fast intake and increase things like b2 . which will spare their iron and start using that copper to get to adrenaline

This is why Ray Peat says , that to raise metabolism you need to get rid of Pufa.



I agree with you Matty , that Ray Peat does not have cases, and that is a problem, if someone already low on PUFA and fats,that someone will run too fast. no doubt and spent tons of iron on doing so.

people can be sick in fast or slow metabolism and have major problems in both.
 
Last edited:

Helen

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
5,415
Another thing to keep in perspective too is high circulating insulin levels which shut down lipolysis. This restricts access to stored EFAs, and deficiencies can develop even faster that way. Saw one study where they put people on parenteral nutrition for 7 days and they developed EFA deficiency in that time span. It was because of fat free diet + no lipolysis from constant infusion of glucose.

of course if you feed high sugar, you will have low fatty acids in blood. even if your intake of them is normal.

Ray Peat loves this scenario, he uses NAD to impair fatty acids release . It was always weird to me. since NAD increases progesterone, and thus potassium which increases cortisol. Obviously cortisol will increase sugar and lower fatty acids .

The whole idea is that this needs to be balanced in people. and Ray Peat could just kill all fatty acids in people with already low fatty acids.

Never understood that. IMO it is stupid. Balance is the key