Is there any evidence that taking Finasteride for a longer time period is more detrimental

djohn051

Well-Known Member
Messages
111
It seems like most PFS cases that I read about involve someone who took the drug for a few weeks or a few months and quit immediately. The onset of my symptoms were far more cryptic and I stayed on the medication for 4 years. Am I going to have a harder time getting back to normal than someone who took the drug for much less time?
 

MNK99

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,560
SOme guy like 40's to 50's was on it 16yrs or so, he told me he got better. Mostly CD's and also natural stuff, but then also TRT. I don't know man. That was email advice I got like 18months ago. He said for his age he needs some TRT and it helped. He said he's with younger girls now, but he had to get divorced and this and that. I was like thanks man.
 

Pedro melo

Well-Known Member
Messages
430
It seems like most PFS cases that I read about involve someone who took the drug for a few weeks or a few months and quit immediately. The onset of my symptoms were far more cryptic and I stayed on the medication for 4 years. Am I going to have a harder time getting back to normal than someone who took the drug for much less time?
Good question... I was on it for two years. Quitiing and coming back wwich I think its even worst coz the body doesn't adapt. And only felt the simptoms after quitting
 

Niles

Well-Known Member
Messages
670
I took it for 2 weeks. I had a minor crash a couple weeks after coming off, a slow decline for a few months, then a worse crash ~10mo off. I took my first pill some time in February of last year.
 

MNK99

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,560
-To Niles:
Wow man.. I took mine Jan 18, last was 124-125 days later (not sure if I made all those doses, but possibly). Definitely slowly declining quite a lot... and then horrible crashing later, rite after quitting and while recovering from surgery, and lasting like 6-7months; till I had no choice but to cleanse. @Niles.
-Probably it did screw me up at 1 to 2 weeks but I wasn't in the right frame of mind, I can tell things hurting me or helping or when I'm indifferent to them, but I thought I needed* Lamotrigine and figured staying on that would make me bald. I could barely get my psychiatrist to send note to my surgeon saying I'm fine for surgery/ and sane and stuff, and I couldn't fax some stuff for recent degree, nor frame it. I got it tho, parents or someone can deal with that (it was over a yr ago!!!)


Re: Is shorter Duration of Finasteride Use Better?
-You could probably argue it either way -- more damage done over a longer time... or less harmful particularly per an individual as duration of use increases - because they didn't feel that labotamy effect immediately... I did pretty much but didn't know what was going on, had to quit it... and knew I'd get sicker - and of course I actually did. Maybe people taking it 12 yrs and only feeling it was problematic at year 9 had less trouble... who knows. It's a terrible drug though for sure.

Long gone now.
 
Last edited:

bruschi11

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
3,011
I took for 2 weeks.

Its all body chemistry and an imbalance. Everyone is different i doubt time matters.
 

joekool

Moderator
Messages
551
@djohn051 hey man two points. A very common situation was ppl starting fin, having symptoms and stopping... And recovering without issue... But then they try it again at some point after recovering, perhaps this time lower dose or every other day, then they get hit with sides so they stop... But this time the PFS crash is worse.

If I were you, I'd cycle down the dosage and cycle in something like anavar in an attempt to bring the body the needed hormones that might overwhelm you post fin.
 

Pedro melo

Well-Known Member
Messages
430
@djohn051 hey man two points. A very common situation was ppl starting fin, having symptoms and stopping... And recovering without issue... But then they try it again at some point after recovering, perhaps this time lower dose or every other day, then they get hit with sides so they stop... But this time the PFS crash is worse.

If I were you, I'd cycle down the dosage and cycle in something like anavar in an attempt to bring the body the needed hormones that might overwhelm you post fin.
@joekool did this happen to you? Coz the second case you spoke is exactly what happened. I've stopped. Started again 3 months later in a lower dose/ every other day and then stopped with a stupid gyno and everything came down... Are you suggesting back on fin again? With anavar?
 

djohn051

Well-Known Member
Messages
111
@djohn051 hey man two points. A very common situation was ppl starting fin, having symptoms and stopping... And recovering without issue... But then they try it again at some point after recovering, perhaps this time lower dose or every other day, then they get hit with sides so they stop... But this time the PFS crash is worse.

If I were you, I'd cycle down the dosage and cycle in something like anavar in an attempt to bring the body the needed hormones that might overwhelm you post fin.

It's too late for that unfortunately. I took Fin for 4 years and quit two times - once at the three year mark where I quit and felt an incredible surge in sexuality. This is where I think I had my crash, but I went back on Fin for 1 more year because I was anxious about losing all my hair. I have now been off of the medication for 2 years. Some things have improved such as my body hair and the tenderness that gave me gyno has also ceased.

Unfortunately though, my libido remains at 0% and my erectile quality isn't great. What I would give to feel sexual energy.
 

Pedro melo

Well-Known Member
Messages
430
It's too late for that unfortunately. I took Fin for 4 years and quit two times - once at the three year mark where I quit and felt an incredible surge in sexuality. This is where I think I had my crash, but I went back on Fin for 1 more year because I was anxious about losing all my hair. I have now been off of the medication for 2 years. Some things have improved such as my body hair and the tenderness that gave me gyno has also ceased.

Unfortunately though, my libido remains at 0% and my erectile quality isn't great. What I would give to feel sexual energy.

BRO tour case is very similar like mine... Did you did something to stop you gyno( I also have but seems better) ...
When you say no libido is like you cant have erections or you need to force it? You don't feel attracted anymore etc?
 

joekool

Moderator
Messages
551
@joekool did this happen to you? Coz the second case you spoke is exactly what happened. I've stopped. Started again 3 months later in a lower dose/ every other day and then stopped with a stupid gyno and everything came down... Are you suggesting back on fin again? With anavar?

Yes the start,stop,recover,start again,stop, crash is my case.

No I’m not saying go back on it tho it’s been theorized. I think anavar shows promise to fix things. My current cycle is helping too
 

djohn051

Well-Known Member
Messages
111
BRO tour case is very similar like mine... Did you did something to stop you gyno( I also have but seems better) ...
When you say no libido is like you cant have erections or you need to force it? You don't feel attracted anymore etc?

Fortunately, the gyno seems to have stopped on it's own, which is nice. It will always be there, but I don't have the tenderness in ny chest anymore.

As for the sexual sides, I never really ever have that feeling of sex drive. I don't really get erections without stimulation and when I do, they don't last very long.
 

Pedro melo

Well-Known Member
Messages
430
Fortunately, the gyno seems to have stopped on it's own, which is nice. It will always be there, but I don't have the tenderness in ny chest anymore.

As for the sexual sides, I never really ever have that feeling of sex drive. I don't really get erections without stimulation and when I do, they don't last very long.
How long did your gyno last? I'm curious coz I'm having my Lumps for three months and they don't seem to grow or to disappear. Do you still feel Lumps on your glandular on the nipples? Or not even that?
 
Last edited:

djohn051

Well-Known Member
Messages
111
How long did your gyno last? I'm curious coz I'm having my Lumps for three months and they don't seem to grow or to disappear. Do you still feel Lumps on your glandular on the nipples? Or not even that?

I still have the glandular tissue for sure. Surgery the only option for that.

The tenderness and growth stopped about a year after I quit.
 

Pedro melo

Well-Known Member
Messages
430
I still have the glandular tissue for sure. Surgery the only option for that.

The tenderness and growth stopped about a year after I quit.
I took tamoxifen for the tissue glandular but it made me feel worst so I stopped. I still have boxes of it if I need... But the first 3 months have passed and for what I know after 3 months tissue can't reverse... So you're niplles are still puffy right? Bad news only with surgery... I thought this could reverse with treatment :(
 

djohn051

Well-Known Member
Messages
111
I took tamoxifen for the tissue glandular but it made me feel worst so I stopped. I still have boxes of it if I need... But the first 3 months have passed and for what I know after 3 months tissue can't reverse... So you're niplles are still puffy right? Bad news only with surgery... I thought this could reverse with treatment :(

Yes, I think if it is set for too long then surgery is the only option. Fortunately mine isn't too concentrated at the nipple so it's bearable. I might consider surgery one day, but with the risk of scarring, it's really replacing on problem with another.

The sexual sides are way worse to me. There's a lot of people doing much worse than I am, but having zero sex drive ever is such a sad feeling.
 

MNK99

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,560
--Easy surgery. I had stomach surgery, my friend lost like 50-60lb (has been ripped and jacked since we were friends but must have been a bit chubby before)...
--He went to the same doc I did for chest surgery. --He had actual gyno he claims.
--Oh yeah actually, he got it done at 18 (doc was shady and friend too young, screwed up my friend). My friend went to a surgeon got it fixed mid 20s. And I went to same doc for stomach (way harder but decent... but it was in pfs crash also and it's more intense surgery. With muscle repair = brutal for sure. I didn't have MR tho).
--Anyways he went back to work on Monday. Got it done on a thurs or fri... Lightly Or he should have waited 10 days then went back to work. --he was fine tho.