---
Neuropsychiatr Dis Treat. 2021; 17: 379–388.
Published online 2021 Feb 10. doi:
10.2147/NDT.S290494
PMCID: PMC7882457
PMID:
33603376
Prevalence of ADHD and Autism Spectrum Disorder in Children with Hypermobility Spectrum Disorders or Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome: A Retrospective Study
Erik Kindgren,1,2
Antonia Quiñones Perez,1 and
Rajna Knez1,3
Author information Article notes Copyright and License information PMC Disclaimer
Go to:
Abstract
Introduction
Hypermobility spectrum disorders (HSD) and hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) are both characterized by generalized hypermobility, in combination with pain, affected proprioception, and pronounced fatigue. Clinical observation indicates that behavioral problems, hyperactivity, and autistic traits are overrepresented in children with those conditions. The purpose of this retrospective study was to establish the prevalence of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and autism spectrum disorder (ASD) among children with HSD and hEDS treated in our clinic since 2012.
Subjects and Methods
Since Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS) diagnostic criteria and international classification were changed in 2017, we equate the older diagnosis EDS hypermobility type with the newer hEDS and the older hypermobility syndrome with HSD. A registry search from the computerized medical record system found 201 children (88 boys, 113 girls) aged 6–18 years who were treated at our pediatrics department with the diagnoses HSD or EDS. All medical records (113 with HSD, 88 with EDS) were reviewed, and key symptoms such as fatigue and pain, as well as diagnosis of ADHD/ASD, were recorded.
Results
All EDS cases could be classified as hEDS. Of the entire study cohort, 16% had a verified ADHD diagnosis and a further 7% were undergoing ADHD diagnostic investigation. Significantly more children with hEDS had ADHD compared to children with HSD (p=0.02). In the age group 15–16 years, 35% of those with hEDS had ADHD and, among those aged 17–18 years, ADHD was present in 46%. Children with coexisting ADHD showed a significantly higher proportion of associated symptoms such as fatigue, sleep-problems, and urinary tract problems. ASD had been verified in 6% of the children. Of those with ASD, 92% had sleep problems.
Conclusion
This study shows a strong association between HSD or hEDS and ADHD or ASD. Therefore, children with HSD or hEDS may need to be routinely screened for neuropsychiatric symptoms.
Keywords: ADHD, autism spectrum disorder, children, hypermobility spectrum disorder, Ehlers-Danlos syndrome
Go to:
Introduction
There are 13 different diseases known as Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS), which usually creates misunderstanding for both patients and healthcare professionals. Twelve of the diseases in the EDS group have verified genetics and are very rare, such as classical EDS (prevalence: 5 per 100,000) and vascular EDS (prevalence: 2–3 per 1,000,000).
1 For hypermobile EDS (hEDS), a genetic cause has not yet been verified, and this disease is much more common than other EDS subtypes. The prevalence of hEDS may be at least 10 per 100,000
1 but the reported figure varies in different studies. Several recent data sources indicate a prevalence from 0.75–2%, and even up to 3.4% in the study to provide a quantification, using joint hypermobility and widespread pain as a proxy for hEDS.
2
Hypermobility is a clinical sign that shows that the range of motion in one or more joints is greater than is considered normal. If the diagnostic criteria for hEDS are not fulfilled but hypermobility is present, the condition may often be classified as a hypermobile spectrum disorder (HSD).
1 HSD and hEDS are both characterized by generalized hypermobility in combination with pain, impaired proprioception, and pronounced fatigue.
2
There is insufficient knowledge of the underlying mechanisms of pain and fatigue experienced by children with HSD or hEDS. Effective treatments are lacking for this patient group, and a recent meta-analysis has shown that most interventions lack efficacy to improve the functioning of these children.
3,
4 They also risk developing chronic pain and suffering exclusion in society.
5,
6 Children with HSD or hEDS show lower self-reported health-related quality of life compared to healthy children, which has been found to be associated with their pain and fatigue.
7 A recently published retrospective study has shown that patients with EDS and those with HSD share a common psychiatric presentation.
8
In everyday clinical practice, we have observed several patient cases with difficult-to-treat pain or pain syndrome (both with and without hypermobility) in whom the pain problems have almost completely regressed since the patient received a diagnosis of attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and received treatment with central nervous system (CNS) stimulant drugs, such as methylphenidate. Clinically, there is also a clear overrepresentation of behavioral problems and hyperactivity, as well as autistics traits, in children with HSD or hEDS. This has aroused our interest to explore in more detail the relationship between HSD or hEDS on the one hand and ADHD or autism spectrum disorder (ASD) on the other.
There are several studies suggesting that hEDS and HSD may be associated with ADHD, though ADHD appears to be more common with HSD than with EDS.
8 There is also increasing evidence that ASD is more common in individuals with joint hypermobility-related disorders than expected by chance.
9 A Swedish national registry study has recently shown that there is a positive association between EDS and ASD or ADHD, and similar results have been observed for HSD.
10
Both ADHD and ASD are neurodevelopmental disorders,
9,
11 which accounts for their similarities as well as for the differences among them. A recent study by Berenguer et al showed that children with ASD (ASD alone or in co-occurrence with ADHD) showed worse theory of mind skills than children with ADHD, while children with ADHD symptomatology (ADHD alone or with co-occurring ASD) had a more extensive profile of executive functions (EF) deficits than children with ASD only.
12 Findings obtained by Craig et al, in their systematic review of EF deficit in ASD and ADHD, are in line with the criteria of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, where these two neurodevelopmental disorders are no longer mutually exclusive. Authors have concluded, based on neurocognitive endophenotype, that rather than a separate condition with distinct impairments, it seems that the common co-occurence of EF deficit reflects an additive comorbidity.
13
The etiology of ADHD is not yet completely understood
11,
14 and most cases of ASD are of unknown cause.
9 Thus, it is not surprising that accepted theories about the underlying mechanisms for relationships between hEDS or HSD and these neurodevelopmental disorders are lacking. Baeza-Velasco et al recently published an explanatory model with at least four different but not mutually exclusive pathways, showing the possible relationships between ADHD and hypermobility: (1) impaired proprioception and, consequently, situations where maintaining motor competences may overload executive functions and attention; (2) musculoskeletal pain that may directly affect attention and concentration; (3) a link between dysautonomia (which is over-represented in HSD and hEDS) and cognitive difficulties; and (4) ADHD and hypermobility having different expressions with a common genetic background.
11
Based on these issues and our clinical experience, in this medical records study we wanted to explore our hypothesis that children with HSD or hEDS have a greater risk of developing ADHD and ASD than the normal population. The Ehlers-Danlos diagnostic criteria were changed in 2017 but we presume that the results of our retrospective study can be relevant to future clinical work because, for example, one study found a similar frequency of comorbidities of hEDS (such as gastrointestinal dysfunction and psychological comorbidities) in those patients who met the new criteria and those who did not.
15
Go to:
Materials and Methods
A registry search from the computerized medical record system covering the period from 2012 to 2018 found 201 children aged 6–18 years who were treated at the pediatric and youth medicine clinic at Skaraborg Hospital, Sweden, with the diagnoses Q79.6 Ehlers-Danlos syndrome or M35.7 Hypermobility syndrome (ICD-10).
16
A review of all 201 medical records (113 with hypermobility syndrome and 88 with EDS) was conducted, and the following variables were recorded: gender, age, place of residence, diagnosis, age at diagnosis, Beighton hypermobility score, fatigue, pain, sleep problems, snoring, sleep apnea, continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) treatment, abdominal pain, constipation, diarrhea, reflux, gastritis, nausea, nutritional problems in childhood, urinary tract problems, ADHD, age at ADHD diagnosis, pharmacological treatment for ADHD, suspected ADHD, autism, Asperger’s syndrome, fulfilment of the old Villefranche criteria for EDS hypermobility type (EDS-ht) from 1997,
17 and fulfilment of the new criteria for hEDS from 2017.
18,
19 Because our registry data predated this change in 2017, we have used the older EDS-ht as a proxy for the newer diagnosis hEDS, as described by the International Consortium on the Ehlers-Danlos Syndromes.
2 We also equate the older hypermobility syndrome with its replacement HSD, in accordance with the 2017 nomenclature changes. Concerning neuropsychiatric symptoms, we equate the registered diagnoses of autism and Asperger’s syndrome with the umbrella diagnosis ASD, in accordance with the nomenclature change in 2013 in the DSM-5.
20 The children in our study were subdivided in two groups based on the diagnosis from the medical records. Thus, in the first group (HSD group) we have 113 children with M35.7 Hypermobility syndrome while in the other group (hEDS group) we have children with Q79.6 Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. None of the children had been diagnosed with, or exhibited symptoms of, any of the rare forms of EDS, such as vascular EDS. Four children were re-examined for classical EDS or classical-like EDS but did not meet the diagnostic criteria. This allowed us to classify all the 88 EDS cases as hEDS, since we equate EDS-ht with hEDS.
The choice of targeting key symptoms (fatigue, pain, sleep problems, gastrointestinal symptoms, urinary tract problems, and neuropsychiatric symptoms) was based on clinical experience with the patient group in the study.
The total number of children in each age group in Skaraborg was obtained through Statistics Sweden, SCB, and in total there were 38,901 children in the age group 6–18 years.
21 The proportion of children with an ADHD diagnosis in Skaraborg was obtained through a register search from the computerized records system.
The Beighton hypermobility scale is a nine-point scale with scores for the presence of any of the following: (a) palmar flexion of the wrist and flexion of the thumb to the volar side of the forearm (one point for each hand), (b) passive dorsal flexion of the little finger more than 90° (one point for each hand), (c) hyperextension of the elbow more than 10° (one point for each arm), (d) hyperextension of the knee joints more than 10° (one point for each leg), and (e) back flexion with legs straight and palms on the floor.
19
e with EDS or HSD’ is not helpful.