*THEORY* Magnesium+Brisket: the cure-all for baldness?!?!

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
So to build on @gbolduev s theory:
Hairloss is either

A) alopecia pattern baldness caused by excessive slow oxidation
B) diffuse thinning / protein wasting caused by excessive fast oxidation
C) a combination of both, caused by mixed oxidation or some kind of drug induced disturbance in the physiology

Lets look at the generic mineral profiles for each:

Slow oxidation has high calcium, high magnesium, low sodium and low potassium. Often excess copper which jacks up calcium even more. The calcium to magnesium ratio is related to calcification. Alopecia pattern baldness seems to originate from calcification. Try to massage and move around the scalp at the sides of your head, then try to move around scalp on top of your head. Is the top stiffer and harder to move? If so, calcification present. So, it seems by deduction that if you are a slow oxidiser with higher calcium to magnesium then you will suffer calcification. Women seem to have hormones protecting them from baldness (atleast until menopause) but men do not and often get patten baldness. But thats not all that would be calcifying either. Joints and blood vessels and all sorts. How many years can the human body last in this physiology before it starts aging faster and enters disease states? So it seems super important to sort this out if not just for vanity!

Fast oxidation has low calcium, low magnesium, high sodium and high potassium. Now i'm not 100% sure of this, but there seems to be a difference in "true fast" and a fast from simply lifestyle choices. For example my step kids are both fast oxidisers (most children are, they're age 7 and 9) and their pattern is: low calcium, medium magnesium, super high sodium, and high potassium. Now the sodium and magnesium ratios are usually related: high sodium = low magnesum. Na / Mg is the adrenal ratio: a high ratio (higher sodium to magnesium) indicates overactive adrenals and lower equals under-active (or burnt out). Adult fast oxidisers from lifestyle could be simply exercise-induced (which is my case) which often raises sodium as the adrenals raise to cope with the stress of exercise, and thus lowers (or uses up) magnesium. So I'd argue with gbold here, that due to high sodium often found in adult fast oxi, that this can cause magnesium to lower excessively past calcium and cause calcification / alopecia pattern baldness too.

So what about diffuse thinning / protein wasting? Common in fast oxidaion often times because this person is just so fast and doesn't replenish enough that all their minerals run low. The biggest one here related to protein seems to be phosphorous, which as gbold has outlined seems to get stuck in a negative cycle. Not enough protein (histidine) means not enough HCL to digest more protein which means protein can just run lower and lower. I had low phosphorous myself and i'm currently experimenting with consuming lots of easily digestible meat, aka slow cooked brisket-style beef. I've actually had some acid reflux from this for the first time in forever, which usually indicates high HCL. A good sign it is digesting.


So if brisket increases phosphorous and addresses protein wasting (not sure of this yet, just started the trial. will have to re-test in 6 months) it looks like zinc and magnesium will increase magnesium. I wouldn't take zinc by itself if you are already in slow oxidation, since it increases calcium too. Zinc would be better for fast oxi. Magnesium as an electrolyte (magnesium chloride) often found in certain products like "Genesis Sea Minerals" or "EDGE Electrolytes" (what ive been taking during exercise: https://au.edgeelectrolytes.com/edge-electrolytes-hydration-mix.php ) seem to be a great option to momentarily balance oxidation in times of stress. They also seem to be super hydrating.

My n=1:
I was in fast oxidation by ARL but slow 4 by TEI (due to low phosphorous) and i seem to have both diffuse and alopecia. I scalp massaged for a year, and now my scalp is much more pliable. However it seems to re-calcify slightly especially after exercise. Now they say the hair test is a summary of your last 3 months of physiology, but our oxidation rate can change on an hour by hour basis. I'm currently trying some electrolyte powders which use sea minerals with the sodium removed during exercise (high in magnesium electrolytes) and it seems to prevent calcification during exercise. As gbold says, its about balancing our individual physiology and we have to learn ways to do so. Everyones context is different but I thought i'd share my current views.


@mattyb @Orion @TubZy
 
Last edited:

MNK99

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,560
I think I had B caused by/ exacerbated by C... And took tons of magnesium for 3 years or so (to potentiate and alleviate side effects of amps).
I don't think i had excessive slow oxidation. I sent out for hair test today... but I'm sure that my normal hair test values vs. on that drug vs. right now (jacked up from finasteride and not on anything) vs. later -- are all going to be different. Possibly I was a slow oxidizer but never lost hair till I was closer to B... Idk - and it was never the "regular" pattern, only diffuse (not that great either, can be way worse if it happens super fast). I have decent hair but I had godly hair.

More positively, outside of digestion issues and if you have too much magnesium, guys and girls don't need to be too worried about ingesting magnesium (I've seen this concern addressed a bit here). I took hundreds of mg daily way before all this. Magnesium helped side effects of amps which for some include hair loss -- but mostly it helped me with bruxism and maybe falling asleep earlier/ not being so shaky.

Edit: Brisket?! I'd love some beef brisket.
 
Last edited:

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
I thin I had B caused by/ exacerbated by C... And took tons of magnesium for 3 years or so (to potentiate and alleviate side effects of amps).
I don't think i had excessive slow oxidation. I sent out for hair test today... but I'm sure that my normal hair test values vs. on that drug vs. right now (jacked up from finasteride and not on anything) vs. later -- are all going to be different.

More positively, outside of digestion issues and if you have too much magnesium, guys and girls don't need to be too worried about ingesting magnesium (I've seen this concern addressed a bit here). I took hundreds of mg daily way before all this. Magnesium helped side effects of amps which for some include hair loss -- but mostly it helped me with bruxism and maybe falling asleep earlier/ not being so shaky.
I think in general for fast oxidation for adults / older teens magnesium deficiency is often problem. Zinc is also supposed to increase it: Mineral Interaction Chart - how to treat ALL imbalances with minerals

I notice zinc really slows me down, helps me get to sleep too
 

Helen

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
5,415
@m_arch I thought about your hairtest and everything. It seems you have a mutation in your aldosterone pathway. Check blood renin aldosterone ratio. It must be high
then body goes an tries to compensate with high progesterone. But since you also have high 5 alpha reductase. This lowers 5 beta reductase and you cant lower aldosterone . IN any case the mutation is in aldo .

This is not fast oxidiation really. This is why zinc and magnesium helped you a little. May be you need tiny amounts of it to support this. or look into blocking aldo receptors. and your hair will grow back. Fin does exactly that it blocks aldo receptors. Same as any other progestins.

I bet you anything that if you do a genetic test 23andme. it will show aldosterone mutation. Also check your progesterone levels. they could be high

so what you need to do is check renin aldo ratio in blood. you might do the genetic test. and then support your mutation.

You can try to load salt like crazy to fix this mutation , don't know if it will work or not.
 
Last edited:

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
@m_arch I thought about your hairtest and everything. It seems you have a mutation in your aldosterone pathway. Check blood renin aldosterone ratio. It must be high
then body goes an tries to compensate with high progesterone. But since you also have high 5 alpha reductase. This lowers 5 beta reductase and you cant lower aldosterone . IN any case the mutation is in aldo .

This is not fast oxidiation really. This is why zinc and magnesium helped you a little. May be you need tiny amounts of it to support this. or look into blocking aldo receptors. and your hair will grow back. Fin does exactly that it blocks aldo receptors. Same as any other progestins.

I bet you anything that if you do a genetic test 23andme. it will show aldosterone mutation. Also check your progesterone levels. they could be high

so what you need to do is check renin aldo ratio in blood. you might do the genetic test. and then support your mutation.

You can try to load salt like crazy to fix this mutation , don't know if it will work or not.
Is the blood test simply called "Renin"? What will it be likely to show?
When I try to load salt like crazy I start to feel a bit weird now.
BTW I did cycle licorice root before (which retains sodium) which seemed to help my dry eyes. But the effects of it seemed to dissipate and at like week 5 I started to feel shitty so I stopped it.
Do you think blocking aldo receptors is a good long term solution?

Actually ive already done a DNA test, which said I had sodium sensitivity and recommended I lowered my salt intake. It said:
"Your genetic tests reveals that you have the "I/D" and Thr/Thr genotype and therefore a possible predisposition to hypertension when salt (specifically sodium) consumption is excessive. You are advised to limit your salt intake to a maximum of 5.5g/day, equivalent to about 2.2g/day sodium."

It said I had the ACE gene, with the ID genotype and the AGTmet gene with CC genotype.
 

Helen

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
5,415
This is what I told you exactly. Check renin and aldosterone in blood and check the ratio renin to aldosterone. they usually do this test . If the ratio is high. your problem is clear. of course you will feel weird on salt, if you retain too much of it. But I am suggesting if you keep at it may be, and I say may be body could mutate back to normal.

Salt loading is not usual in this condition, usually you need to block aldo receptors sligthly
 

Helen

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
5,415
Look at this this way/ Your aldo is higher than it needs to be with your renin. Body tried to compensate and raises progesterone and keeps it high to retain potassium since this high aldo is wasting potassium . But in stressful situation , this progesterone converts to cortisol, and you get hypokalemic fast. This is why in this body chemistry it is hard to handle stress.
 

Helen

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Messages
5,415
zinc and magnesium is hard in this case. since they will increase aldosterone receptors even more. You need aldo agonists to try to cure this mutation. or you need to block aldo receptors always, but that will make them even stronger.
 

Ivy

Member
Messages
42
I appreciate your efforts towards a general theory, @m_arch. I do feel that the hypothesis is slightly outdated, as you're the second person to whom gbolduev recently suggested to check aldosterone to renin ratio.

So does the original dichotomy still stand? How does it relate to aldosterone to renin ratio? Also, how about connective tissue degradation or keratin problems? I've seen them mentioned as well, are they additions to the theory?

Hope someone can pitch in.
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
This is what I told you exactly. Check renin and aldosterone in blood and check the ratio renin to aldosterone. they usually do this test . If the ratio is high. your problem is clear. of course you will feel weird on salt, if you retain too much of it. But I am suggesting if you keep at it may be, and I say may be body could mutate back to normal.

Salt loading is not usual in this condition, usually you need to block aldo receptors sligthly
OK I will get my renin and aldosterone checked tomorrow.
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
"A functional polymorphism of the human ACE gene has been identified in which the presence (insertion: I allele), rather than the absence (deletion: D allele), of a 287-bp Alu repeat element in intron 16 (rs4646994) is associated with lower enzyme activity in both serum and tissue (12, 39), resulting in greater production of ANG II and aldosterone and a decreased half-life of bradykinin (4, 52)."


Despite the SNIPs status, testing would be best to show if there is current altered values in those hormones.
Maybe the report mentions which exact were the rs# identified for each of this SNIPs ?
Hmm that was all the info it gave me. It was with dnaFit

Btw where did you get that info from? Does it say anything about the AGTmet gene?
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
@m_arch I thought about your hairtest and everything. It seems you have a mutation in your aldosterone pathway. Check blood renin aldosterone ratio. It must be high
then body goes an tries to compensate with high progesterone. But since you also have high 5 alpha reductase. This lowers 5 beta reductase and you cant lower aldosterone . IN any case the mutation is in aldo .

This is not fast oxidiation really. This is why zinc and magnesium helped you a little. May be you need tiny amounts of it to support this. or look into blocking aldo receptors. and your hair will grow back. Fin does exactly that it blocks aldo receptors. Same as any other progestins.

I bet you anything that if you do a genetic test 23andme. it will show aldosterone mutation. Also check your progesterone levels. they could be high

so what you need to do is check renin aldo ratio in blood. you might do the genetic test. and then support your mutation.

You can try to load salt like crazy to fix this mutation , don't know if it will work or not.
Gbold, i got my labs back.

Aldosterone: 657pmol/L ref (100-950)
Renin: 24mU/L ref (3-40)

Aldo/renin ratio: 27 ref (<50)

Looks like a normal ratio? Btw my secobd hairtest came back also My second hair test w/ comparison - 28/2/18
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
To add to this thread...

Men are supposed to be zinc dominant but due to excessive ejaculation (whats excessive right?) But in relation to zinc replenishment, i think that directly relates to baldness.

I.e. on the hair mineral chart, zinc is the only mineral to cause magnesium retention in the cell. Thus we're literally ejaculating out zinc, causing our magnesium to fall.

The calcium to magnesium ratio is what decides calcification. Pattern baldness is calcification of the scalp. Low magnesium to calcium causes calcification.

The other side of the spectrum is fast oxidation and protein wasting. Guess what? Zinc is sedating and good for fast oxidisers too since it retains calcium and magnesium. The only thing here is you probably want to add some calcium or copper if you take zinc and are fast, since zinc lowers copper absoprtion and fast oxis have low copper usually. And have more fats, which is also supposed to improve the mg to ca balance.

@TubZy @mattyb @gbolduev @Orion


Gbold i now understand why you say manganese and zinc for slows. I think it needs to be clarified, this only works for a classic slow 1. It will lower ca and mg while raising na and k. Rarely do we see a classic anything on this place, i think cobtext is king and everyone needs to examine their test before takibg anythibg.

What did you recommend for a fast again? Copper and what?
 
Last edited:

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285

Orion

Well-Known Member
Messages
879
To add to this thread...

Men are supposed to be zinc dominant but due to excessive ejaculation (whats excessive right?) But in relation to zinc replenishment, i think that directly relates to baldness.

I.e. on the hair mineral chart, zinc is the only mineral to cause magnesium retention in the cell. Thus we're literally ejaculating out zinc, causing our magnesium to fall.

The calcium to magnesium ratio is what decides calcification. Pattern baldness is calcification of the scalp. Low magnesium to calcium causes calcification.

The other side of the spectrum is fast oxidation and protein wasting. Guess what? Zinc is sedating and good for fast oxidisers too since it retains calcium and magnesium. The only thing here is you probably want to add some calcium or copper if you take zinc and are fast, since zinc lowers copper absoprtion and fast oxis have low copper usually. And have more fats, which is also supposed to improve the mg to ca balance.

@TubZy @mattyb @gbolduev @Orion


Gbold i now understand why you say manganese and zinc for slows. I think it needs to be clarified, this only works for a classic slow 1. It will lower ca and mg while raising na and k. Rarely do we see a classic anything on this place, i think cobtext is king and everyone needs to examine their test before takibg anythibg.

What did you recommend for a fast again? Copper and what?

You can see from my hairtests(in sig), that I had levels that would not be associated with shedding, but I am shedding alot, probably due to calcification from crappy diet years before the two tests and I started working on this...
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
You can see from my hairtests(in sig), that I had levels that would not be associated with shedding, but I am shedding alot, probably due to calcification from crappy diet years before the two tests and I started working on this...
Yeah i guess if calcification has set into the scalp, its not going away quick unless you do something (massage, salt rubs, that phosphorus thing gbold said)
 

Orion

Well-Known Member
Messages
879
Yeah i guess if calcification has set into the scalp, its not going away quick unless you do something (massage, salt rubs, that phosphorus thing gbold said)

I did the massage thing a few years ago, the full 10months(20mins morning, 20mins night), it did nothing, but again this was before all the Peating, fasting, and now protocols on this forum. I started the massage routine morning and night two weeks ago, hoping it will help, shedding just won't stop! Doing just few mins in the morning and night, 40mins a day just to much wasted time...
 

Aleksandr

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,285
I did the massage thing a few years ago, the full 10months(20mins morning, 20mins night), it did nothing, but again this was before all the Peating, fasting, and now protocols on this forum. I started the massage routine morning and night two weeks ago, hoping it will help, shedding just won't stop! Doing just few mins in the morning and night, 40mins a day just to much wasted time...
Looking at your latest hair test, you need to get your CA: MG ratio below 7. Your calcium is too high relative to your mg, so calcification won't stop. It wasn't too bad though, so it s houldnt be too hard. But you know these things fluctuate and the graph is only an average. I wouldn't be surprised if you had days of scalp itch and days of no scalp itch. Ideally you wanna get it below 7 permanently.

potassium and magnesium might help you, or potassium and zinc (or all 3)

1522196392228.png